05/07/2026
I have now reviewed the Monitoring Officer’s decision notices from South Cambridgeshire District Council regarding my standards complaints.
After waiting over six months for a response, and only receiving the decision notices after writing to Liz Watts, the Chief Executive of South Cambridgeshire District Council, one point stands out very clearly.
In 11 out of 11 decision notices I reviewed, the Monitoring Officer relied on the same wording:
“Based on the information provided it is unclear if the Subject Member was acting in their official capacity. Therefore it is unclear if the Code applies.”
That means in 100% of the decision notices I reviewed, the Monitoring Officer said it was unclear whether the councillor was acting in an official capacity.
This raises serious concerns about how the Monitoring Officer dealt with these complaints.
Surely the first question should have been:
In what capacity was the Councillor acting in relation to each complaint — as Parish Chairman/councillor, or as a private individual?
That question goes to the heart of whether the Members’ Code of Conduct applied.
If it was unclear whether the councillor was acting as a councillor, Parish Chairman, or private individual, why was that not clarified before the complaints were dismissed?
In my view, if the Monitoring Officer considered this point unclear, the proper and common-sense step should have been to ask that question, investigate it, and record the answer — not use that uncertainty as a reason to dismiss the complaints.
It also raises questions about why it took over six months to reach effectively the same conclusion across each decision notice.
I also have to question whether a temporary or interim Monitoring Officer was ever in the best position to fairly and fully deal with complaints involving long-running concerns, previous council actions, legal involvement, and parish council conduct. If the Monitoring Officer’s conclusion in every decision notice was that the key issue was “unclear”, then that suggests the matter required proper investigation — not repeated dismissal.
I am not simply saying I disagree with the outcome. I am questioning whether the complaints were properly assessed, whether the Monitoring Officer made sufficient enquiries, whether the issue of official capacity was properly investigated, and whether residents can have confidence in the standards process.
The complaints involved matters connected to Parish Council meetings, parish minutes, parish correspondence, the Parish Clerk, reports connected to parish matters, and actions or comments made by councillors/chairmen in relation to council business.
In those circumstances, I believe it was reasonable to expect the Monitoring Officer to apply common sense and establish clearly whether the councillor was acting in an official capacity or as a private individual.
If the key issue was “unclear”, then surely the answer was to clarify it — not dismiss the complaints because it was unclear.