10/10/2026
Nearly 12,000 students. That’s how many students Alabama’s public schools have reportedly lost in just one year. That should concern every Alabamian.
According to the article, several factors may be contributing to this decline, including population shifts, declining birth rates, and more families choosing private schools or homeschooling, particularly with expanded school choice opportunities through programs like the CHOOSE Act. While the extent to which each factor is contributing remains unclear, it’s important that we fully understand what’s behind these numbers.
To be clear, the CHOOSE Act is NOT solely responsible for this decline. As Dr. Mackey has pointed out, the numbers simply don’t support that conclusion. However, as we work to better understand the factors contributing to this decline, the potential impact of expanded school choice should be part of that broader analysis.
These numbers demand answers, reliable data, and a plan moving forward.
And that plan must include accountability, transparency, and reasonable minimum standards for ANY non-public school, program, or individual accepting taxpayer dollars to educate Alabama’s children.
I respect a parent’s right to choose the educational setting that’s best for their child. But public dollars should come with public accountability. Those principles are not mutually exclusive.
Incidentally, as PARCA’s recent survey revealed, a majority of everyday Alabamians feel the same way.
Without common-sense guardrails, we risk creating an environment ripe for waste, fraud, and abuse. Even worse, we may not discover the consequences for student learning until years later, when those young people enter college or the workforce. By then, it’s too late.
We need these safeguards NOW, while we work to understand what all is behind this significant enrollment decline and what it means for the public schools that continue to serve the overwhelming majority of Alabama’s children.
This shouldn’t be about public schools versus private schools. It’s about protecting taxpayers, ensuring accountability, and doing what’s right for ALL Alabama children.
Alabama public school enrollment is down to about 702,000 students from 714,000 last year, Mackey said.