13/04/2026
When Philosophy Becomes Partisan: Unmasking the Bias in Hagher's "Followership Crisis' Essay
Monday, April 13, 2026
The essay by an elder statesman, Professor Iyorwuese Hagher, titled “Nigeria’s Followership Crisis: Why Bad Leadership Thrives in Benue and Beyond” unveils a sound philosophical reflection on what exactly is "civic responsibility".
It is a sound essay, ordinarily, raising the fact that citizens, through their choices and orientation, form the quality of leadership they operate under.
However, its application to Benue State under the leadership of Governor Alia, drifts from balanced analysis into a carefully intellectualised partisan, selective narrative disguised as a leadership essay.
The narration attempts to universalise the concept of “followership failure” while it tip-toes smartly confining its practical application to one "targeted" political actor, thereby shifting from objective diagnosis to targeted indictment.
Prof Hagher downplays the constitutional structural realities of insecurity in Nigeria that no single governor can solely tackle. None, not one.
They are all constrained. So, isolating Benue’s security challenges without rational and adequate emphasis on constitutional reality is, at best, incomplete, and at worst, deliberate intellectual fraudulence.
The essay fails to sufficiently fit Benue’s insecurity within the broader national chaos, as from the North-West to the Middle Belt and beyond, local communities continue to contend with banditry, insurgency, etc.
Reflecting Benue’s situation in total disconnect from national reality governance risks grossly misleading readers. Of course, that seems to be the original import of the Essayist.
Noticeably, the essay is reluctant to acknowledge the ongoing incremental gains that sub-national Benue is making. Nothing of such makes the essay more an intellectual camouflage to get at Governor Alia.
To dismiss progress amidst Benue’s insecure environment on the basis that it does not meet the Essayist's threshold is to demand perfection in a context that requires or should require persistence.
Another curious concern is the tone used in ascribing the governor’s political engagements with the Benue publics.
Professor Hagher knows that democratic politicking, involves contestation, and symbolic mobilisation. This is open to criticism no doubt, but exaggerating them into proofs of incitement or instability on Alia singularly betrays a lack of balance.
How often does Prof Hagher consult? How does he expect to be consulted? Taking the lead to speak for all Benue stakeholders suggests a crafted purpose not to critique, but to delegitimise.
Unfortunately, Hagher's essay itself exemplifies the very problem it claims to interrogate, address or pass an opinionated verdict on.
On one hand, the essay calls for objective citizenship but its author prefers modelling Alia selectively for criticism. The essay cautions against propagandizing, yet tilts heavily on emotionally charged interpretations!
Civic responsibility demands consistency of standards which from an intellectual's lens ought to be applied across stakeholders, across time(s), and across political persuasions.
While Governor Alia, or any leader, should be insulated from criticism, intellectual scrutiny or criticism ought to be fair and contextual. Possibly solution-driven as well. It shouldn't be to inflame under any intellectual cloaking. Not ivory towered political points hunt.
The people of Benue understand the density of their circumstances and context. Interestingly, they are not quite inspired or moved by politically motivated alarming essays.
When statesmen reframe blame rather than providing solutions or broadening collective responsibility across national and state-level institutions, and publics it helps little. Shifting narratives from “bad leadership” to “bad followership,” especially when such shifts are selectively weaponized is simply a disguised version of intellectual fraudulence.
Progress comes from honest engagement and enquiry, powered by shared accountability and not in partisan intellectualism.
Governor Alia is not burdened or interested in choosing between defending leadership and condemning followership. He wants a re-engineered Benue where both leadership and followership are held to the appropriate standards of responsibility, integrity, and measurable commitment to the common good, while he provides the needed leadership as captain of the ship.
Sir Tersoo Kula, mnipr
Chief Press Secretary to the Governor of Benue State.