10/03/2026
A Cautionary Tale:
🏡 How does a small township with rural character, vital environmental resources, and one lane roads end up with an approved site plan for industrial construction measuring hundreds of thousands of square feet in size? The answer is a bit more complex than what will be explained, but the simple truth is that it took planning and conversations among elected officials and the developers who wanted it to happen as part of the Redevelopment Zone Plan.
📋 In April of 2023, Andover Township’s Master Plan Reexamination Report was published. Its purpose, according to New Jersey Statute, is to ensure that current development regulations within the municipality align with its goals, and recommend changes to be implemented. This report specifically addresses warehouses and recommends that their size be limited to conform more clearly to the goals of the master plan. It further highlights that due to a lack of centralized infrastructure that is costly to implement with scarce resources, zoning for small planned industrial parks would be a more suitable option so that its impact can be absorbed. Mega warehouses were distinctly discouraged as an option. The Township paid for this reexamination to use as a guideline for their decisions, to zone accordingly, and to choose projects that complement the town’s goals.
One month later, in May 2023, National Land Developers presented a concept plan to the Township Land Use Board. The plan was explained as two industrial warehouses totaling over 700,000 square feet. There was no application or end user in place. The purpose of this presentation was merely to propose such an option for the parcel on Stickles Pond Road. This is not an unusual function of the Board - who asked questions and performed their responsibilities. However, this is where the idea of a very large scale industrial warehouse was born, contrary to the aforementioned Master Plan Reexamination Report.
Shortly thereafter, in June of 2023, a Town ordinance was introduced and subsequently approved to include warehouses as an additional permitted use within the Redevelopment Zone. This was always the intent according to the ordinance and based upon reports, but now it was codified. The stage was set.
📊 Fast forward again to summer of 2024. The Land Use Board reported the results of a survey sent out to residents regarding what they want for Andover Township in accordance with the Master Plan. According to the minutes of the June 18, 2024 meeting, residents' responses included a need for commercial space, but specifically said FEWER warehouses and more passive entertainment open space such as walking trails, community gardens and dog parks. This is what residents want.
📦 Yet, around this same time, summer of 2024, National Land Developers was back with a completed application for a proposed 650,000+ square foot warehouse at the same location and a proposed end user - a furniture storage and shipping warehouse. In October of 2024, the applicant presented to the Land Use Board.
🚛 The size of this facility is arguably larger than the vast majority of projects within the township, designed with 130 docking bays for tractor trailers and approximately 100 employees. A traffic study was conducted for one day and it was deemed that a minor change to one traffic light would sufficiently mitigate increased traffic congestion. 80 tractor trailers and 100 employees on Stickles Pond Road, Route 206, and arguably other one lane town roads? A 4 second light delay will do the trick? There was no study done to evaluate the effects of an additional 80 diesel engines daily in an environmentally sensitive area with over 20 acres of wetlands adjacent and the Pequest considerations. There would be no security guard presence but agreed to create a parking area for local Andover Township police to monitor traffic given the increased volume and potential danger.
⚠️ Additionally, the applicant would need relief from necessary steep slope disturbances and other waivers for their design. This meeting was held in accordance with legal requirements but with little additional notification or social media attention and subsequently almost no public participation or commentary. Yet, despite the size, scope and magnitude of the project, the preliminary and final site plan were approved - in one evening - on one of the largest industrial warehouse projects the town would have to date.
❓ There has been some question as to whether the proposed end user was even still interested in the property at the time of the presentation and approval. We do not know. However, despite the fact that the furniture distributor did not end up building this warehouse, the approval still exists. National Land Developers was now free to market the property touting Andover as a pro development town with approved plans for an enormous warehouse and 40+ million in potential tax savings to the end user over 30 years with a PILOT program.
⏳ Presently, the owner of the property has asked for an extension of their final site plan approval for an additional year. The approval for a warehouse still exists indefinitely. The extension insulates them from any zoning changes moving forward that would limit or change the scope of the existing plans.
🗳️ This is a cautionary tale: who you elect matters. Transparency, open communication, and a willingness to work with residents matters. Working within the confines of existing town studies and recommendations that were thoughtfully researched matters. Taking responsibility and fixing mistakes without claiming victory or spinning the narrative matters. That is why we are running - to put Our Town First.
- Cynthia Chase and Nicole Guerrieri for Andover Township Committee