09/10/2026
213 years ago today, the Battle of Lake Erie began the morning of September 10th. At 7am the squadron of nine U.S. Navy ships under the command of Commodore Oliver Hazard Perry, formed and prepared to engage the enemy British squadron of 6 ships led by Royal Navy Commander Robert Barclay.
This would be the culmination of a month of scouting by Perry, searching for the British and a year of shipyard preparation, construction, outfitting, and crewing. Perry is supposed to have said "this is the most important day of my life" to his friend and Purser Samuel Hambelton, before the battle began.
The Battle:
The shooting began at 11:45am, though the maneuvering and positioning had begun hours earlier as both sides sought the greatest advantage relative to the wind. A shot from a British 24lb gun hit "Lawrence", Perry's flagship. The battle seesawed for over three hours. The light breeze meant the ships were moving so slowly that it took Perry the next 45 minutes to close the range from about a mile down to the 200 yards or so at which range carronades were most lethal. During all this time Lawrence continued to receive fire she could not answer except with the 2 long 12-pounders. By 12: 30 Perry was able to open fire in earnest. Because Elliott failed to close, Perry found himself under fire from both the large British ships and a smaller brig as well. The concentration of force at this point was completely with the British. The result of this situation was that for the next two hours, Lawrence fought an artillery duel on very uneven terms. While her own 32 lb. carronades were inflicting great damage on the British, the combined weight of fire of Detroit, Hunter, and Queen Charlotte eventually put all of Lawrence’s guns on the engaged side out of action. Eighty percent of the men fit for duty on Lawrence were casualties, 22 killed and 66 wounded, a proportional toll seldom exceeded in the age of sail.
Perry had the great good luck to remain uninjured while his ship became a shattered slaughterhouse around him. With both guns and crew gone, there was nothing more that could be accomplished from the Lawrence. Perry further had the luck that one of the ship’s boats was still intact towing astern. Perry saw that Niagara was still undamaged and determined to continue the fight from her, using the boat to transfer. Perry turned over Lawrence to Lt. Yarnall, who later struck the U.S. flag to surrender to avoid further useless slaughter.
Perry’s transfer to the decks of Niagara is perhaps one of the most recognized moments in the Battle of Lake Erie. For many artists, this is the moment they choose to replicate. That said, it was sheer luck that Perry was not only able to survive but, then continue the fight and eventually win the day. Once aboard, Oliver took command from his next in command, Jesse Duncan Elliott, and raised his banner high above the decks of Niagara. In a moment of confusion, the British believed the Americans to be retreating however, they were actually pressing on, taking advantage of the weather gauge (favorable winds). It is here where the two largest vessels in the British squadron, Queen Charlotte and Detroit run into one another, becoming entangled in a mess of rigging. Perry saw the opportunity - a moment to unleash sheer devastation on the unsuspecting British ships. Niagara was ordered to close in and swing into the British line.
“At 45 minutes past two, the signal was made for “closer action”. The Niagara being very little injured, I determined to pass through the Enemy’s line; bore up, and passed ahead of their two Ship and a Brig, giving a raking fire to them from the Starboard guns, and to a large Schooner and Sloop from the Larboard side, at half Pistol shot distance. ”
- O.H. Perry in his after action report
Within 15 minutes of Perry’s transfer, the British squadron surrendered - the Battle of Lake Erie was over.
This is just an excerpt from our website. Want the full timeline of the battle? Click below!
https://www.eriemaritimemuseum.org/research-topics/battle-of-lake-erie
Image (Prelude to Battle) courtesy of Peter Rindlisbacher