Pony Express

Store closing! All merchandise must be sold! 40% off sale.

To Our Erie Community and Loyal Pony Express Customers,
It is with a heavy heart that we announce our decision to close Pony Express and retire at the end of December 2025.
As many of you know, Terry and I have been planning to retire and sell our business. Since November 2024, we’ve had a committed buyer ready to continue serving this community. Unfortunately, the USPS Retail Group in Washington, D.C. has placed a hold on all transfers of existing and new contracts with private businesses, which has led to the cancellation of the sale.
What does this mean for our customers?
We will remain open through the end of the year, continuing to offer:
• Forever and Christmas stamps, as well as international stamps
• UPS and FedEx shipping services as well as packing.
• A selection of packing & retail supplies as well as cards and gifts
We sincerely thank you for your loyalty, trust, and support over the past 36 years. Serving this community has been our greatest honor.

Frosty made his debut ❄️🩵⛸️
Good thing we have stamps for the holidays !

Give the gift of imagination !!
Mermaids to Knights to Royal Princesses 👸🏼
Now 75 % off … get them at $7.50

We have stick on earrings and nail art too !

Get the flashing Halloween necklaces before they’re gone!


Halloween is almost here. Stop in and get your Halloween cards or merchandise at 50% off.

We are open again thanks to Steve and Nancy. Thank you for your understanding.

Unfortunately Pony Express will be delayed opening today due to morning shift not feeling well. Will hopefully open this afternoon.