09/29/2026
Toby Bethel reflects on a day that changed his life forever
By Charlotte Burrous
In the aftermath of 911, Fremont County had its own tragedy to contend with just 17 days later.
It started out as a normal day for Fremont County. When Deputy Sheriff Jason Schwartz was sent out on a call to Penrose, he found twin brothers Joel and Michael Stovall had shot and killed a dog. Deputy Schwartz and Deputy Escobel handcuffed the twins, but did not search them. The two deputies put the twins in the back of the vehicle and began transporting them to jail. During the ride, one of the twins shot Schwartz several times in the head. He later died in the hospital.
In the meantime, Florence Police Cpl. Toby Bethel had a day off on Sept. 28, 2001, and was enjoying an evening with his family. During this time, the twins drove the police car across U.S. 50 to Florence.
âI guess they put on bulletproof vests, a helmet and stuff like that,â Toby said. âThey get their AK47; they get their SKS and they get ready to get out of here, I guess. I was at home with Misty and got the call that Deputy Schwartz had been shot in the head and probably wasnât going to make it.â
Although it was his night off, when he got the news of the shooting, he got dressed and drove his vehicle to pick up Officer Eric Baker at the police department. He drove to the trailer park, where the twins were leasing a trailer.
âWe were just going to back off and just watch,â Toby said. âIf we saw them, we were going to call the SWAT team to take them. As I drove up to the space number, I tell Eric there it is. I saw some shadows off to my side, but I didnât think anything of it. As I drove by a red pickup, I remember hearing (the shots). I remember feeling the burn in the middle of my back and looking over at Eric and said, âoh no, they got us, didnât they?ââ
He drove out of the trailer park, through a chain link fence across Third Street through a plowed hayfield into a tree. Soon as he got shot, he said he felt the burn in his back and probably âwent into shock immediately,â he added.
âCome to find out, they shot me with an AK47; shot me twice in the middle of my back, once in my shoulder and once in my arm,â Toby continued. âI remember, trying to reach the top of the car and pull myself out the window then I went unconscious.â
The next thing he said he remembered is hearing the late Chief Gene MacKinnon, of the fire department saying âToby, hang in there. Toby, weâre going to get you out of here. I remember it, but I donât. The next thing I know I remember hearing John Wysong. I was in the ambulance. I remember waking up and see John. I remember saying, âIâm going to die, arenât I?â He yelled at me and said, ânot in my ambulance, youâre not.ââ
At that point, Toby was taken to St. Thomas More Hospital, where they operated on him all night long. Then he was transported with Flight to Life to St. Anthony Central in Denver, where he remained for about a month until he was transferred to Craig Rehabilitation Hospital. Thatâs where he learned to use the wheel chair.
But he remains hopeful.
âI look back and stuff happens to people, Bethel said. âWith this, Iâve learned how to live being paralyzed. Itâs not been an easy life, but there are people out there that live a rough life. God has been good to me.â
Best of all, his family has stood by him and has been a huge comfort to him.
When the incident happened, Bethelâs parents, Kenneth and Sharon Bethel were camping in Missouri when they got the call at 3 a.m. They packed up and drove to St. Louis and purchased airplane tickets to Denver.
âWe walked in and told them what happened,â Kenneth said. âThey said âcome with us.â TWA got us two tickets to Denver, that quick. Amazing.â
They didnât have to go through the check lines and stand around for hours.
âThey walked us through,â Kenneth added. âWe got to the hospital and he was still coherent. He said he doesnât remember, but he talked some. We stayed with him for six months. He went to Craig and I got to stay with him, especially in Craig. He had to roll over every two hours. I got the night shift to help turn him over. All the people, the police department, law enforcement were amazing with support for him. Itâs quite a brotherhood, isnât it Toby,â who agreed with his father.
It was the same for his wife, who was with him the whole time along with their four children.
âMisty stayed and my four kids,â Bethel added. âIâve got 12 grandkids. Iâve got this business now. Itâs Mistyâs business. Iâm the manager. Things are good. Iâve got my whole family out here with me.â
He and Misty recently opened Mattress by Appointment at 115 E. Main St. in Florence.
Toby continues to look forward to the future.
âSometimes life beats us up,â Bethel said. âWeâve just got to do the best we can. We opened this business up here in Fremont County because this is home. I just hope people will come in and use what weâve got going. We did it for Fremont County. Itâs home.â