Sullivan County Historical Society & Museum

Directions Website Contact the organization

Sullivan County Historical Society & Museum Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Sullivan County Historical Society & Museum, 265 Main Street/PO Box 247, Hurleyville, NY.

The Sullivan County Historical Society was established on September 18, 1886 to preserve the history of Sullivan County for the enlightenment of future generations.

11/06/2026

RETROSPECT
by John Conway
November 6, 2026

FALLSBURG’S BICENTENNIAL

A significant anniversary went by largely unnoticed this spring, completely overshadowed by the celebrations surrounding America’s 250th birthday.

The Town of Fallsburg turned 200 years old in March. It is a milestone worth noting, even if belatedly.

In his 1873 History of Sullivan County, James Eldridge Quinlan writes that Fallsburgh (the “h” wasn’t officially dropped until 1968) “was erected by an act of the Legislature of New York, on the 9th of March, 1826, and taken from Thompson and Neversink.”

Quinlan further records that “the act declared that the first town-meeting should be held at the schoolhouse near the Neversink Falls on the first Tuesday of April, 1826. At this meeting the following persons were elected: Herman M. Hardenbergh, Supervisor; Richard A. Reading, Town Clerk; John Crawford, James Brown and Cornelius D. Eller, Assessors ; Harley E. Ludington, Henry Misner and John Eller, Commissioners of Highways; Elnathan S. Starr, Thomas Lawrence and John Hill, Commissioners of Common Schools ; Henry Mead and Josiah Depuy, Overseers of the Poor ; Warren Barlow, Collector ; Warren Barlow, Philip C. Ludington, Daniel Couch, and Alexander C. Sloat, Constables ; and Thomas E. Hardenbergh, William Hill and Julius I. Starr, Inspectors of Common Schools.”

And Quinlan observed that “the migratory habit of our people is illustrated in the fact that more than one-half of the family-names which appear in the above list are no longer borne by residents of the town.”

Of course, regular readers of this column know that the original plan for organizing the town did not include the name Fallsburgh (or Fallsburg) at all. The first inclination was to name the newly formed town Lockwood, after Thomas St. John Lockwood, and this would have been done, except for the protestations of the man himself, who, Quinlan records, "thought no resident was entitled to the honor of having his name thus perpetuated."

There is no denying that the town of Fallsburg owes much to Lockwood, who bought out the saw and grist mills built in 1808 and 1809 by Henry Reed and Herman Ruggles when he came to this area. He also purchased the mill of Jacob and Thomas Powell. As Quinlan writes, he "accomplished much in developing the natural resources of the Falls. He erected buildings, and induced others to settle in the place." He eventually owned five mills at the falls, including a paper mill.

Lockwood was instrumental in the construction of the Ulster-Orange Branch Turnpike, which was chartered in 1808 and completed in 1818, and in the construction of the stone arch bridge over the Neversink at Old Falls, built in 1819 (it was destroyed in 1952 to make way for a "more modern" structure). The turnpike, which much aided development and settlement of the town, began at the Newburgh-Cochecton Turnpike in Montgomery, and passed through Burlingham, Roosa Gap, Summitville, and Sandburg, and then through Old Falls and on to Liberty. The roadway was constructed with funds obtained by taxing the landowners who resided within five miles of it. When many of these landowners were unable to pay the resulting property taxes and their parcels were auctioned off, Lockwood bought thousands of acres at the tax sale. He owned over 10,000 acres of land at his death in September 1837.

It was the fact that the Neversink River flowed within its boundaries that led to the initial growth of Fallsburg. Specifically, it was the Neversink Falls, the 23-foot drop in the river which provided not only the original name of the hamlet in which it was located, but eventually of the township itself. Quinlan wrote that "the water power of Fallsburgh is almost inexhaustible, and with enterprise and capital sufficient to render it available, may yet add immensely to the population and wealth of this town."

Of course, by the time Quinlan was writing, the hamlet had a number of thriving industries, despite having lost one of its most lucrative, the tannery. Prior to that time, in the words of Hamilton Child, in his Gazetteer and Business Directory for Sullivan County 1872-73, tanning "was one of the leading branches of industry" in the town of Fallsburgh. And one of the principal tanners, Rufus P***n, became one of the most important and influential men in the town’s history.

P***n came from a family of tanners in Ulster and Greene Counties. He arrived in Fallsburgh in 1831, and with his partner, Matt Adams, established one of the first tanneries in Sullivan County, utilizing the falls for power and the water from the river to treat the hides. The P***n tannery was able to tan from 10,000 to 15,000 hides, but it was soon outpaced by other tanneries capable of turning out 35,000 hides or more.

Rufus P***n was elected to Congress in 1838. As a consequence of this, Edward and Arthur P***n and their cousin Nicholas Flagler, became active in the P***n tannery at the falls, which soon became known as P***n & Flagler. It survived Rufus P***n’s death from tuberculosis, and thrived during the Civil War, but was shut down shortly thereafter because of a lack of bark.

From that point on, the town of Fallsburg has had to re-invent itself many times. From the industrial center of Sullivan County, it became one of the county’s most prominent resort areas. With the demise of the hotels, the prisons within the town provided employment for hundreds throughout the county, and another major employer, Sullivan County Community College, now known as SUNY Sullivan, opened its doors in 1963. The town is also home to several of the oldest family-owned businesses in the county.

It has been an eventful 200 years, to be sure, but who can doubt there will be much more to come?

John Conway is the Sullivan County Historian. E-mail him at [email protected].

PHOTO CAPTION: A view of the Neversink Falls through the arches of the stone bridge in Old Falls.

10/30/2026

A Hometown Son, A Lasting Legacy
Historical Society, Sullivan County Bar unite to remember Judge Cooke

A historical marker honoring Lawrence H. Cooke, the Monticello native who rose to become chief judge of New York’s highest court, was dedicated Tuesday, October 27, at his longtime family home on West Broadway.

To continue reading click here: https://www.scdemocratonline.com/stories/a-hometown-son-a-lasting-legacy,256951?

Article and photo by Sean Kuhn

10/25/2026
10/24/2026

Leslie Loeffel will make two presentations on the history of Kenoza Lake:



"Kenoza Lake: A Social History” - What was it like to live in a wilderness? Work in a tannery? Spend the summer in a boarding house? Step back in time and experience life in Kenoza Lake through the 19th century and into the 20th. Wednesday, November 18, 3 pm at the Jeffersonville Branch of the Western Sullivan Public Library, 19 Center St, Jeffersonville.

To continue reading click here: https://www.scdemocratonline.com/stories/leslie-loeffel-to-present-on-the-history-of-kenoza-lake,256164?

10/23/2026

RETROSPECT
by John Conway
October 23, 2026

R.I.P. MIKE

Michael Francis Conway, my cousin who grew up next door to me in Rock Hill, passed away earlier this month. He was 69.

Much of Mike’s childhood was spent trying to keep up with his older brother, cousins, and neighbors, but it wasn’t long before he developed an independent streak that saw him forge his own path without much regard for what anyone else thought. He was a U.S. Army Airborne Ranger, and became a truck driver, like his father.

But most of all, Mike was a hunter. He loved the woods, and he loved the thrill of the chase. It was his passion, and one he came by honestly. It was in his blood.

A great grandfather—and namesake—was a legendary hunter and hunting guide whose notoriety often landed him in the pages of the New York Times, and occasionally in this column. Whenever the latter occurred, Mike would inevitably reach out, letting me know that he had caught the reference. It became a way for cousins who seldom saw one another anymore to keep in touch.

The legendary hunter was Frank King of Monticello, who was the 20th century equivalent of the prolific hunters and colorful tall-tale tellers from Sullivan County’s past made famous by writers like Alfred B. Street, James Eldridge Quinlan, and Stephen Crane. Born too late for his exploits to be chronicled by those literary luminaries, King had to settle for many of his stories gaining credibility by virtue of their publication in the Times.

By Frank King’s time, and maybe due at least in part to his prowess as a guide, Sullivan County had developed a reputation as "probably the finest deer country in the State of New York."

For example, there were 489 deer taken in the county in 1933 and 567 the following year. By 1935, the Times was reporting that in proportion to its size, Sullivan "is said to rank next to Pike County, Pa. as the most heavily populated deer area in the East, if not in the country. The shooting here is regarded as good if not better than that to be found in the Adirondacks."

That November, some 4,000 hunters descended upon Sullivan County for opening day; State Game Protector George Hembt considered it a "normal turnout." Many of those hunters were distributed throughout over 500 camps throughout the county, and most hunted on lands closely protected the rest of the year.

"The best deer country is controlled by clubs which own large tracts, such as the Hartwood Club, with 22,000 acres, and the Merriewold Club with 3,000 acres," the Times reported on November 3, 1935. "The Rockland Light & Power Company owns some 30,000 acres of land that is thick with the animals, while the famous Bradford estate of 18,000 acres, a virtual deer preserve, this year is being leased in strips to individual guides, camps, and clubs."

The Times reported that Frank King led a party of 15 hunters on a portion of the Bradford estate on opening day in 1935, and although they failed to bag even one buck, it was - perhaps predictably - one that got away that provided the most excitement.

King reported that one of the hunters in his party that day wounded a tremendous buck -"it was believed to have had at least twenty points" - and trailed the brute through the mountains for three miles, only to lose the trail in the laurel thickets.

For more than a decade, King was regularly consulted by and quoted in the Times regarding all things hunting, usually in a section entitled “Wood, Field and Stream.”

In an October 19, 1935 article, the paper reported that grouse were especially plentiful throughout the Catskills that season.

“W. E. Scudamore writes from East Windham that grouse are plentiful in Greene County. He took his limit of three on the opening day. Woodcock also are in flight there, he adds. Art Flick of Westkill, which is in Greene County, recently informed the writer that prospects for grouse shooting in that section were excellent. Favorable reports also were received from Frank King of Monticello regarding conditions in Sullivan County.”

And in a November 21, 1939 Wood, Field and Stream article under the headline, “Ducks Wary and Scarce For Winter Game Feeding,” the Times noted that, “In predicting that the week-end would be something in the nature of a Roman holiday for the deer hunters of the Catskill area we weren't far wrong, according to the reports that came in yesterday. Several camps in the Neversink area of Sullivan County began driving in earnest and were successful in almost every instance. They found that the greater number of deer seemed to have concentrated in the swamps, and the standers were posted on the edges while the drivers went through the muck and sedge. There seemed to be an unusual number of small buck taken.

“Frank King reported that a very large buck, weighing about 230 pounds dressed, was shot by one of the members of the Toohey camp, which adjoins the old Bradford preserve along the Neversink. Evidently we should have tarried at Billy Ziegler's camp, for John Bernius shot a nice buck the morning after we left.”

The references go on and on. So much so, perhaps, that those who are left to mourn Mike’s passing can take some solace in the fact that in the happy hunting ground we all aspire to attain in death, he might well have found a hunting partner who shares his bloodline as well as his passion. RIP, cousin.

John Conway is the Sullivan County Historian. Email him at [email protected].

PHOTO CAPTION: Mike Conway in 2024.

10/09/2026

RETROSPECT
by John Conway
October 9, 2026

THE END OF THE SEASON AT FORT DELAWARE

One of the highlights of the 2026 season at Fort Delaware Museum of Colonial History in Narrowsburg, NY was the return of the exhibit featuring the original handmade buckskin jacket worn by founder James W. Burbank in the early years of the Fort’s operation.

Obviously influenced by the Davy Crockett craze that was sweeping the nation in the aftermath of the 1955 Walt Disney television mini-series about the frontier hero, Burbank—and occasionally other Fort Delaware employees at the time—had often appeared on the premises clad in the fringed jacket, matching pants, and a coonskin cap.

While not at all authentic for the colonial era depicted at Fort Delaware, the buckskin get-up appealed to youngsters of the day, and families swarmed to Narrowsburg, their interest fueled in part by the excitement generated by the nation’s fascination with Davy Crockett.

Initially intended by Walt Disney simply as a way to promote his upcoming Disneyland theme park, the Davy Crockett craze evolved into one of the most famous media fads of the 1950s, as in 1955 alone, Americans purchased more than $300 million in Crockett themed merchandise, including bubble gums cards, lunchboxes, drinking glasses and mugs, phonograph records, and, of course, buckskin jackets and coonskin caps.

While Burbank’s cap and trousers have been lost to time, the jacket survived, and was a central piece in the longstanding museum exhibit that helped illustrate the story of Burbank and the Fort’s founding.

But time eventually took its toll on the jacket, as well, and it was in such poor condition by the time The Delaware Company took over operation of Fort Delaware in 2021, it was finally removed from display. Cost estimates for cleaning it and preserving it properly were solicited from museum textile firms throughout the country, but in view of other priorities, the jacket was packed away, with as much care as possible.

Enter Elsie Kopcha and Howard Wasserman. Both Harris residents have been loyal volunteers at Fort Delaware for several years, and in 2025 they made the decision that the museum was lacking something significant without the Burback jacket on display. While “the other Fort Delaware story,” chronicling Burbank’s efforts to turn his vision into reality and the obstacles and influences he dealt with in getting the place opened in 1957, remained an integral part of the narrative at the Fort, the presentation did not seem complete without the jacket as a visual aid.

So largely through the generosity of the two volunteers, The Delaware Company was able to ship the jacket off to Museum Textile Services in Boston for preservation. Subsequently, the jacket has been returned to display this year, and will play a significant role in next year’s activities at the Fort, which will be celebrating its 70th anniversary in 2027.

In the meantime, visitors will have a final opportunity to view the Burbank jacket—and all of the other outstanding features of Fort Delaware—this coming weekend, which will be the last two days of operation for 2026. Among other things, visitors can participate in authentic colonial era games, learn about the agricultural practices of the Cushetunk residents, visit an authentic 18th century apothecary and hear about treatments and remedies used on the frontier, visit with a woodworker and a blacksmith, and witness musket demonstrations and firings.

It is worth noting that in recognition of the end of another season, the gift shop at Fort Delaware will be offering special discounts on all its merchandise, ranging from books to toys and games to tee shirts and sweatshirts and coonskin caps, including items specific to the commemoration of America’s 250th birthday.

In addition to the discounts in the gift shop, the closing weekend will also feature a number of contests and games, with prizes awarded to children and adults for feats of skill and knowledge.

Fort Delaware is open on Saturday and Sunday, October 10 and 11 (weather permitting) from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m., but no one is admitted after 4 p.m. The Fort is located on the Upper Delaware Scenic Byway at 6615 Route 97 in Narrowsburg. It has been operated by the Barryville based nonprofit history education group, The Delaware Company since 2021. Visit thedelwarecompany.org for more information.

John Conway is the Sullivan County Historian. His email is [email protected]. Visitors to Fort Delaware this weekend can hear his narration about James W. Burbank, the Fort’s founding father, for the last time in 2026 as the Fort closes for the season at the end of the day on Sunday, October 11.

PHOTO CAPTION: The original handmade buckskin jacket worn by James W. Burbank in the early years of Fort Delaware has been returned to display.

Address

265 Main Street/PO Box 247
Hurleyville, NY
12747

Opening Hours

Tuesday 10am - 4:30pm
Wednesday 10am - 4:30pm
Thursday 10am - 4:30pm
Friday 10am - 4:30pm
Saturday 10am - 4:30pm
Sunday 1pm - 5pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sullivan County Historical Society & Museum posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Organization

Send a message to Sullivan County Historical Society & Museum:

Share

Nearby government services


Other Hurleyville government services

Show All