10/09/2026
I am cautiously optimistic the rest of the Board will vote with me on Nov. 4th to make these rules voluntary rather than mandatory..
By Janis Mara | [email protected]
PUBLISHED: October 8, 2026 at 1:42 PM PDT
More than two dozen rental housing providers and property owners spoke out against a proposed gas water heater ban at the Bay Area Air District’s board meeting Wednesday.
The proposed mandate affects portions of Solano County, including Vallejo, but not Vacaville, and the Bay Area counties touching the bay. The regulation was not on Wednesday’s agenda, so the board didn’t discuss it; the speakers addressed the board during public comment. The board is scheduled to consider the matter on Nov. 4.
Two concerns surfaced again and again: The cost of replacing a gas water heater with an electric one, and the amount of notice given to the public about the proposed rule.
Speaking through a translator, an Asian homeowner told the board, “We are against the mandate to change water heaters to electric. Because electrification is very costly, we cannot afford it.”
A 72-year-old retiree and landlord said, “An estimate to upgrade my electrical system is in six figures. I can’t afford that.
“My units are rent-controlled,” said the landlord, who owns a 90-year-old, four-unit property in San Francisco.
“If I had to spend $150,000, I would lose my property,” he said, predicting that the regulation would worsen the already “totally distorted rental market in San Francisco.”
Along those lines, “We are the people who have to come up with the solutions to this new regulation. We are the ones who have to bear the cost,” said Brian Wallace, president of the Small Property Owners of San Francisco Institute.
In the Bay Area, replacing a standard 30-50-gallon gas tank water heater with another gas tank model typically costs between $2,200 and $4,500.
The cost of purchasing and installing a typical heat pump water heater would add $3,500 to that expense, according to a regulatory overview document on the Air District website.
The proposed ban doesn’t require anyone to proactively replace a gas water heater. It goes into effect when the water heater is broken or worn out, applying “only to new water heaters purchased or installed after the compliance date, so property owners make the switch when the appliance reaches the end of its life,” air district spokeswoman Miranda Iglesias said via email.
Many of the speakers asked the board to do away with the mandate altogether. Failing that, they asked for more time for it to go into effect.
“Why couldn’t we make this in five or 10 years?” Wallace asked the board.
Another speaker said, “I am all for having a great world. I support electrification, but not the mandate. This is something people need to plan for, not something you just spring on people, ‘Oh, your water heater went out, and you have to replace it with an electric.’ It’s a huge shock.”
The board passed the measure in 2023 and released a statement on its website announcing the change at that time, but the news only got out to the general public around late 2025.
Originally scheduled to start Jan. 1, the ban was one of the most stringent regulations in the U.S. with the goal of phasing out gas water heaters and furnaces, both of which emit pollutants known as nitrogen oxides.
The news of the ban sparked public outcry, making it one of the most controversial environmental policies in the Bay Area.
Solano County Supervisor Monica Brown and Benicia Mayor Steve Young, who both serve on the Air District board, urged the district at a May meeting to replace the mandate with a voluntary program.
By a close vote of 10-8, the board didn’t take the suggestion. Instead, the board directed staff to develop a proposal with potential flexibility measures and exemptions “intended to address affordability concerns and installation challenges for residents and small businesses,” according to spokeswoman Miranda Iglesias.
The new draft proposal reflects the board’s direction. It delays the implementation date from January 2027 to January 2028. It also exempts low-income property owners and situations where electrical panel or physical space constraints make the transition to cleaner appliances especially difficult or expensive.
The board is scheduled to consider this new draft Nov. 4.
The amendments fall into three broad categories: Low-income property owners, properties without enough room or ventilation to install a compliant unit, and electrical limitations such as panels below 100 amps, insufficient panel capacity, or a need to run electrical lines more than 50 feet.
Before the meeting, referring to the amendments, “The Air District understands that cost is a real concern for small property owners and owner-occupant landlords for transitioning, and the Board of Directors has heard those concerns directly,” Iglesias said.
Only one speaker at Wednesday’s meeting, Fernando Gaytan, a senior attorney with Earthjustice, a nonprofit environmental law organization, supported the proposed regulation. He urged the board to “stay the course.”
The rule would deliver cleaner air and prevent up to 85 premature deaths each year, according to the district. Additionally, it would improve overall regional air quality from the outdoor venting of these appliances and avoid up to $890 million per year in health impacts due to air pollution exposure.
A report from the air board’s staff concluded that water heaters and furnaces in the Bay Area generate 3,690 tons of nitrogen oxides a year, a key component of smog. That’s more than all passenger vehicles in the Bay Area, the agency says, which emit 3,464 tons a year.
Air pollution from gas-powered furnaces and water heaters is one of the largest sources of nitrogen oxide emissions in the Bay Area, the district said. These pollutants contribute to smog and fine particulate matter, which can worsen asthma, increase the risk of heart and lung disease, and disproportionately impact communities already facing higher pollution levels.
Hence, the district said, reducing emissions from building appliances will help create healthier indoor and outdoor environments, reduce climate impacts and ensure cleaner air.