09/24/2026
To the community, Supervisor Quigley and Members of the Town Board:
Over the past several years, our leadership and town board have advocated for police transparency and legitimacy. Last year, board members asked, "What do you guys do? The public needs to know." While answered in more ways than one, nothing has changed: our call volume and crime rates continue to increase (confirmed by DCJS stats), while our retention rates continue to plummet.
On behalf of the members of the Ulster Police Benevolent Association, we respectfully ask: What are we worth?
Last year, after a financial review revealed an abundance of unallocated funds, the Ulster PBA submitted a proposal requesting a minimal compensatory adjustment for the remainder of our contract through 2028. Despite multiple requests, formal letters, and in-person inquiries, we have received no response. While the town discusses growth—such as the Kingston Motel and other projects—and the resulting burden on resources, nothing has been done to address that burden.
For context, during a recent shift, three officers handled 34 calls for service—an average of 11.3 calls per officer, ranging from lockouts to disputes to shots fired calls. We consistently operate at minimal staffing, leading to prolonged response times and decreased community presence. Furthermore, we are losing both new and senior officers to neighboring departments with more competitive pay scales, and current conditions hinder our ability to recruit replacements. Many of our officers must work second jobs. In addition, for years, officers have dealt with sewage backups in Ulster Police Headquarters ("the basement"). Over the past two weeks, department members have worked under deplorable conditions, including inoperable facilities, degraded air quality, putrid odors causing physical illness, and disruptive demolition noise. Attached are photos and videos documenting these conditions.
These issues directly impact the residents of our town, who deserve adequate staffing, prompt response times, and a safe, clean environment when visiting the police department.
Despite EXTREMELY low morale, we continue to answer the public's calls and serve our community. If you will not answer us, please answer the residents: What is the police department and its members worth?
Ulster Police Benevolent Association