03/11/2026
Why have the INDIA bloc and its Constituent Parties Suddenly Stopped Talking about ‘Reclaiming Jantar-Mantar’?
When the Modi-Shah government denotified Jantar-Mantar as the protest site in Delhi on 12th October due to its fear of beginning of a 24x7 sit-in dharna at Jantar-Mantar for removal and arrest of Gyanesh Kumar and roll-back of SIR, the Congress and Rahul Gandhi did say that they will reclaim Jantar-Mantar. The other constituent parties of INDIA bloc, too, parroted this claim, including CPM, CPI (ML) Liberation, etc. However, on 12th October itself, the day Jantar-Mantar was denotified, the INDIA bloc organized a huge rally but instead of reclaiming Jantar-Mantar, ended up circling around the round-about of Supreme Court! Then, again, various parties of INDIA bloc repeated that they will indeed reclaim Jantar-Mantar. However, the masses kept waiting that INDIA bloc or one of its constituent parties will give the call for mass march towards Jantar-Mantar, but in vain.
Slowly, all these ‘parties of power’ (electoralist bourgeois parties) stopped even mentioning the call to reclaim Jantar-Mantar. Neha Bora, the new poster girl of liberals, left-liberals and liberal-left, organized many media-managed “barricade runs” before the issue of peace bond came up. Once the issue of peace bond came up, Bora did a lot of tubthumping that she will not sign any peace bond. However, without signing the peace bond, she is complying with the basic conditions of the peace bond! That is, instead of disobeying the fascist government by marching to Jantar-Mantar, she and her party CPI (ML) Liberation, too, have obeyed the fascist government by joining the INDIA bloc “rally” at Ramlila Maidan, a site allowed by the Modi-Shah government! We have not seen any of the celebrated “barricade runs” of Ms. Bora since then!
And what came out of the 1 November Ramlila Maidan “rally” of the INDIA bloc? The promise of fighting a “legal battle” to remove Gyanesh Kumar and roll back of SIR! If that is all that these bourgeois electoralist parties intended to do, then what was the point of Ramlila Maidan “rally”? They could have simply fought the case in Hon’ble Supreme Court! And what has the Hon’ble Supreme Court done so far? In the beginning it consigned to trash bin all the petitions challenging SIR! Now, it has adopted the tactics of deferring any real and decisive verdict on SIR roll back, despite the open and glaring anomalies in the affidavit filed by the ECI! What hope can the masses harbor from Supreme Court and CJI Suryakant? If this deferring continues, then the coming 2027 state elections have already been won by the BJP! Why? Because as a result of SIR (even after addition of several voters later!) 13 percent of votes in all the states scheduled for legislative assembly elections have been deleted!
If elections are held with such large-scale deletions in place, shouldn’t the opposition parties give a call for the boycott of these elections? Shouldn’t they accelerate the anti-SIR Mass Movement? Shouldn’t they immediately undertake the task of reclaiming Jantar-Mantar, which is, tactically-speaking, the most important task of this movement at present?
However, instead of unleashing the revolutionary mass initiative for fulfilling this task, the INDIA bloc parties are actually limiting and regulating the mass initiative by making the masses go round and round bourgeois legalism and constitutionalism. In fact, nothing is surprising in this, as these ‘parties of power’ are fulfilling their historical and political function. And the role of the parliamentary ‘left’ is most disgusting in this whole affair as it co-opts the radicality of the masses through bombastic rhetoric, while doing nothing substantial, and neuters it.
Now that the Ramlila Maidan “rally” of INDIA bloc is over, what is next? Just loitering around the corridors of Supreme Court? The masses are demanding a substantial step of this democratic movement. It is becoming increasingly clear that the parties of INDIA bloc neither have the will nor the capacity to respond to this demand of the struggling masses. They are hell bent upon limiting this movement within the limits posed by the fascist government of Modi-Shah. That is the reason why they have stopped uttering single word about reclaiming Jantar-Mantar. Instead, they are engaging in non-sense regarding “making each home Jantar-Mantar”! What are the masses supposed to do? Install a statue or a figure of Jantar-Mantar in their houses, just like a house mini-temple? Each city and each village, too, can become Jantar-Mantar, only if the actual Jantar-Mantar in Delhi is reclaimed. All of us know that such places do not remain mere geographical locations. They become a political site, a place for churning of mass movements, a symbol of the struggle of the people.
The INDIA bloc parties, that is, the ‘parties of power’, have stopped talking about Jantar-Mantar, because denotification of Jantar-Mantar as a protest site gives manifestation to their hidden wish, too. The entire ruling class and its political representatives (including Congress, RJD, SP, TMC, CPM, CPI (ML) Lib., etc.) want to push such people’s places of protest to the outermost periphery of the city. Ramlila Maidan is in central Delhi but it is a paid site. Who can pay such hefty amounts to book Ramlila Maidan for raising their legitimate democratic and economic demands? Certainly, not the working masses! Only ‘parties of power’ have such resources at their disposal. Therefore, snatching away the free-of-cost sites of democratic protests at central places is, de facto, a ban on all democratic protests, not simply Jantar-Mantar.
However, the INDIA bloc parties are now keeping a mum on this issue. Why? Because all ‘parties of power’ and the ruling class, whom they represent, tremble with fear when scores of people gather at Jantar-Mantar near the parliament, the bunglows of MPs-MLAs at Lutyen’s Delhi and shake them with their revolutionary slogans. That is the reason why the INDIA bloc and its parties have stopped talking about reclaiming Jantar-Mantar and are blabbering gibberish regarding “creating Jantar-Mantar in every house”!
In response to this betrayal of the anti-SIR mass movement by these bourgeois and petty-bourgeois parties who are refusing the take the most important immediate step of the movement and frustrating the masses by making them go round and round ad infinitum in the legal-judicial-constitutional round-about which has never brought any significant change, the revolutionary forces in the movement must form a united front against fascism and rally the masses to reclaim Jantar-Mantar, in order to remove and arrest Gyanesh Kumar and force the Modi-Shah government to completely roll back SIR. This is the most important immediate step of the movement and it is indispensable. RWPI calls upon all genuine revolutionary parties, organizations and individuals to come forward and make such a united front of the working people.
Also, we must remind the unsuspecting well-meaning people of the progressive intelligentsia that this criticism of the parties of bourgeois opposition in no way weakens the movement. In fact, not undertaking this criticism is already weakening the movement and taking it to a slow death, exactly what the Modi-Shah government wants. The only way to take this movement forward is by process of criticism and minimization and elimination of the errors being committed by various forces active in the movement. The movement can progress only if it is able to purge itself of the capitulationist bourgeois and petty-bourgeois leadership. RWPI is undertaking this criticism only after making repeated appeals to the parties of INDIA bloc to undertake a substantial and real step to reclaim Jantar-Mantar. We must not forget that it was the 24x7 sit-in protest at Jantar-Mantar which succeeded in bringing the Modi-Shah government to its knees during the recent student-youth movement. And we must also realize that it was precisely due to this bad experience that Modi-Shah government denotified Jantar-Mantar.
We appeal once again to all genuine revolutionary, progressive, democratic and secular parties, organizations and individuals to come forward and form a united front of the working people against the fascist regime of Modi-Shah.