Vanderburgh County Prosecutor's Office

Call Directions Website

Vanderburgh County Prosecutor's Office The Vanderburgh County Prosecutor's Office promptly pursues justice and continues to seek improvements in the criminal justice system.

The Vanderburgh County Prosecutor’s Office is charged with the responsibility of representing the State of Indiana in all felony and misdemeanor criminal prosecutions resulting from crimes committed within Vanderburgh County, Indiana. In addition, the Vanderbrugh County Prosecutor’s Office conducts criminal investigations, supervises Grand Jury proceedings, enforces child support orders entered in divorce and paternity cases, conducts juvenile adjudications and prosecutions, and provides information and assistance to the victims of crime.

Dear Members of the Indiana Parole Board,As the Prosecuting Attorney for the First Judicial Circuit of the State of Indi...
11/05/2026

Dear Members of the Indiana Parole Board,

As the Prosecuting Attorney for the First Judicial Circuit of the State of Indiana which is comprised of Vanderbugh County, I stand in opposition to the clemency request of Jeffery Weisheit and ask that you recommend the death penalty sentence be imposed on November 5, 2026, as set by Order of the Indiana Supreme Court.

The board can consider certain factors at this clemency hearing and the ones I am here to highlight are: the nature and circumstances of the offense and what’s in the best interests of society. I intend to add brief remarks regarding the affect of this case on society—specifically the people of Vanderburgh County and also regarding Caleb and Alyssa Lynch and their mother, Lisa Lynch.

To be clear, I was not in the prosecutor’s office when this crime occurred but this case is still very alive in our community, to our first responders, to the courts, and in the halls of my office. I commend all of those who responded that day and who were involved in carrying this case through to the finish. Thank you to Deputy Attorneys General Angela Sanchez, the Chief Counsel for Appeals at the Attorney General’s Office and Tyler Banks, Section Chief for Capital Litigation at the Attorney Generals Office, and their colleagues, for carrying this case through to the finish.

Vanderburgh County

The Defendant left a lasting negative impact on Vanderburgh County’s first responders and citizens. This trial was moved to a different county in partial recognition that the heinous crime commited by Weisheit and its impact on the community was so vast that it hindered the abiltity to find a jury of his peers in Vanderburgh County to hear it. Vanderburgh County was, and still is, consumed by news of the horrible murders of two completely innocent children and left with imagining the pain and grief felt by their mother Lisa Lynch—who not only lost her two children but also her home and belongings to the fire set by Weisheit. Anyone familiar with this case will never forget the facts of what Jeffrey Weisheit did to five-year-old Caleb and eight-year-old Alyssa Lynch, nevertheless, it is important to state it with these remarks. The Indiana Supreme Court summarizes the heinous actions of Weisheit in their August 28,2026, Order Setting Ex*****on Date.

Five-year-old Caleb Lynch and eight-year-old Alyssa Lynch were left in Weisheit’s care whle their mother worked. After becoming irate at Caleb, Weisheit shoved a washcloth into his mouth which was secured with duct tape, Weisheit then hog-tied the child using duct tape, put a railroad flare into his underwear and one under his body and set him on fire on a mattress. Caleb was burned beyond recognition but fire officials testfied that he was alive while his left thigh was burnt by the railroad flare -eventually the mattress he was laying on caught fire and he suffocated. At trial, when Weisheit was cross examined about the severe burns to Caleb’s leg he said: “things happen.” Eight-year-old Alyssa Lynch was found by fire personnel in a closet—over 90% of her body was charred black and the pathologist testified that she may have burned while she was still alive or as she asphyxiated from the soot and smoke inhallation.

Vanderburgh County first responders, court personnel, and citizens will never forget these horrific facts which they are forced to discover and re-live each time Jeffrey Weisheit files a brief or request. For the victims’ families and first responders who lived this horrific experience, the effects of the endless litigation are even more severe. The proceedings regarding Weisheit, who was charged in 2010 and convicted in 2013 after a jury trial, have been significant—he has sought post conviction relief by way of direct and post-conviction appeals and habeaus petitions in the State and Federal Courts.

We can’t imagine what the last thoughts of those sweet children must have been- yet the citizens of Vanderburgh County, and many other parts of the State and even country, undoubtedly ask themselves this question when they read about the facts of this case. We are all worse off for experiencing this case. We can only pray that God intervened for Caleb and Alyssa quickly and gave them peace from their suffering. Weisheit was the last person they saw- someone who was in charge of taking care of them. Now, our state and community has spent over a decade concerned with the rights, preferences and concerns of Jeffery Weisheit., the prosecutors first had to prepare the case and prove him guilty beyond a reasonable doubt—the highest burden in the law. Everyone involved had to prepare for years and relive that horrible day as we are right now. When the trial is done, the Defendant is afforded numerous appeals, hearings, considerations, discussions and medical examinations—even up until days before this hearing the Defendant has requested more medical exams for something that was aleady addressed in his sentencing at the trial court—and so we see his name in the paper again. The law swings heavily in favor of Defendants. It seems nearly impossible for a death sentence to be carried out and, on the way there, it has cost the State hundreds of thousands of dollars and hundreds if not thousands of hours of collective work from the courts, probation, medical staff, and attorneys.

Jeffrey Weisheit has hurt our society, degraded the sanctity of human life, desecrated two young children, and exposed many in Vanderburgh County to an unimaginable horror that they will live with forever in some way. I hope that on November 5, 2026 Weisheit’s requests (which cause headlines to bring up his name and the collective trauma in our county repeatedly) can come to an end when his ex*****on is carried out.

Caleb and Alyssa Lynch

As has been the case for over a decade, Jeffrey Weisheit’s name is said over and over, and his rights and wishes considered, while the memories of victims are cut short. I want to share some final thoughts about Alyssa and Caleb Lynch from the trial transcript. They would be young adults today but the Defendant’s actions have frozen them in time as small children.

I want to share memories of them. In June of 2013, teachers of Alyssa and Caleb were called to testify at the Defendant’s trial. Alyssa’s elementary school teacher Mrs. Hamilton described Alyssa as soft spoken, polite, and mannerly – she had fun on the playground at recess but, when it came time for it, she was in her seat and ready to learn. When Mrs. Hamilton was asked about Alyssa, she said she wished she had ten children just like her. Caleb’s pre-school teacher Mrs. Gomez described Caleb when he was in her pre-school class in 2010: He loved playing as any five year old does and was very gregarious and talkative. Mrs. Gomez said Caleb loved making little noises and joked that he must have had a job as a ventriloquist at some point- because he would make the noises but you didn’t know where they were coming from. She said the word that comes to mind when she thinks
of him is loving—he was an extremely loving little boy.

Some will argue that life in prison is the way to handle this case but the only way to ensure justice and put an end to the endless collective trauma which is relived by all with each of the Defendant’s endless filings and requests is to put an end to Weisheit’s voice once and for all. Unlike Caleb and Alyssa, the children he burned alive and their mother (who lost everything and must live with that unbearable pain), he had a choice that day and has been given extensive consideration and due process. The death penalty was the sentence recommended by the jury, reviewed by our courts, and so it is justice.

Every person should be afforded the full protections of the United States Constitution and the due process it brings—this is truly what makes America the best country in the world.

Jeffrey Weisheit has exhausted his constitutional protections and so the answer is final—the death penalty should be imposed. May God have mercy.

Sincerely,
Diana L. Moers
Prosecuting Attorney, First Judicial Circuit
Vanderburgh County, Indiana

SAMUEL HUGGLER, EXTRADITED FROM SPAIN AND FOUND GUILTY AT TRIAL, RECEIVES 120 YEARS FOR MURDER-FOR-HIRE PLOT TO KILL HIS...
10/22/2026

SAMUEL HUGGLER, EXTRADITED FROM SPAIN AND FOUND GUILTY AT TRIAL, RECEIVES 120 YEARS FOR MURDER-FOR-HIRE PLOT TO KILL HIS FAMILY

​EVANSVILLE, VANDERBURGH COUNTY, Ind. — Prosecutor Diana Moers announces that on October 21, 2026, Samuel Steven Huggler was sentenced to serve 120 years in the Indiana Department of Correction. The Honorable Ryan D. Hatfield of the Vanderburgh County Circuit Court presided.

On December 14, 2021, Daniel Alvey shot three people at the Huggler family home, located in a subdivison on the east side of Evansville, killing 18-year-old Olivia Huggler and severely wounding her brothers, Jonathan and Joseph. The family had just returned from Christmas shopping when the shooter came to the home at the direction of Samuel Huggler to kill Jonathan Huggler and all of the witnesses. Charges were filed but later dismissed.

Upon taking office in 2023, Prosecutor Moers took command of the case and worked with international authorities, including the United States Department of Justice and federal law enforcement in the United States and Spain, to apply for and secure an international arrest warrant for Samuel Huggler. Huggler, who moved to Andorra, near Spain, was arrested and extradited to Vanderburgh County in April of 2025.

Alvey pleaded guilty in 2023 and received a 45-year prison sentence—he then testified against Samuel Huggler at trial. Alvey’s testimony corroborated the State’s case which included photographic evidence, digital forensic evidence–including cell phone location data and communications between the co-defendants–statements of the Defendant, eye-witness statements, and videos. Following a seven-day trial in August of 2026, a jury found Huggler guilty of felony murder and three additional level 1 felony charges involving conspiracy to commit murder and aiding, inducing, or causing attempted murder. The jury found the State proved the aggravating circumstances outweighed the mitigating circumstances to meet the criteria for life without parole, but chose to have Huggler sentenced to a term of years instead.

During the sentencing hearing, several witnesses, including Huggler family members, read victim impact statements. Those statements included the pain and grief caused by the Defendant, and the physical and emotional impact that the death of Olivia and the shooting in their home caused their family. Surviving brothers Jonathan and Joseph testified to the physical and emotional pain they live with each day.

The Court sentenced Huggler to 60 years for the murder of Olivia Huggler; 25 years for the attempted murder of Joseph Huggler; and 35 years for the attempted murder of Jonathan Huggler. These will be served consecutively for a total of 120 years in prison.

“This was an exceptionally complex case that required years of investigative and prosecutorial work to bring Samuel Huggler to justice. Samuel Huggler spent years putting his own family in fear—using religious manipulation and threats which eventually escalated to reality when he manipulated and hired Daniel Alvey, a foster kid he knew from church and befriended, to carry out his crimes. It was an international effort to bring him to justice for good reason—Samuel Huggler poses a great danger to the people of Vanderburgh County and especially the Huggler family. I want to thank my partners at the United States Department of Justice, the FBI, and the Spanish police force. They listened to the Huggler family’s story and cared enough to help.

I am proud of the efforts of my office. I tried this case with Stan Levco and our team assisted us greatly in getting hundreds of exhibits and over twenty witnesses prepared for trial. Special thanks to victim advocate Robyn Mastison who has walked the journey with the Huggler family since this crime happened in 2021. Thank you to our trial support team Jen Savage, Morgan Richardville, Boston Bradley, and Woody Burrell. Investigator Jon Carter from our digital forensics lab and our Evansville Police Department detectives and first responders worked diligently on this case including: Ret. Detective David Bonenberger and his wife Laurel, who provided immediate aid and shelter to the family and critically wounded, EPD Detectives Trendon Amuzie, Jonathan Oakley, Dillon Powers, Aaron McCormick, Arnie Juncker, Kyle Thiry, crime scene Detectives Phil Luecke and Jeff Brievogel, Indiana State Police lab personnel, and many officers, firefighters, and first responders.

Together, our team worked diligently to connect the evidence, present witness testimony, and demonstrate the role Huggler played in planning this shooting. Huggler was used to successful manipulation and abuse of his siblings, but that ended when they called for help that night. Because of this community and the bravery of the Huggler family, Sam Huggler will no longer be among us in Vanderburgh County and we are all safer for it. Sentencing is an important step in holding him accountable for his actions and the devastating consequences for the Huggler family.

While no sentence can undo the loss of Olivia or erase the immense physical pain and trauma her brothers now have to live with as gunshot survivors, we believe this outcome reflects the seriousness of these crimes and provides some measure of justice for the victims and their loved ones.


ABOUT THE OFFICE OF THE VANDERBURGH COUNTY PROSECUTOR

The mission of the Vanderburgh County Office of the Prosecuting Attorney is to effectively and efficiently represent the State of Indiana in criminal court proceedings; maintain a fair and diligent pursuit of justice; invest in technology and training opportunities to fuel an innovative approach to prosecution; deepen partnerships and collaboration with law enforcement agencies; invest in community endeavors that work to better the circumstances of crime victims; partner with organizations who are working to combat crime and/or provide services to crime victims; and continue to protect, serve, and advocate for the citizens of Vanderburgh County.

Prosecutor Diana L. Moers was elected to the Office in 2022.

Prior to being elected, Diana was a trial attorney with over 15 years of experience. She supervised a large section of trial attorneys in state and federal courts, and is an experienced prosecutor for domestic violence, white collar crime cases, and aggravated child abuse cases. Victims of violent crimes can rest assured they have an experienced fighter in their corner.

DEFENDANT FOUND GUILTY IN STORAGE UNIT BURGLARY INVOLVING FI****MS  VANDERBURGH COUNTY, Ind. — Prosecutor Diana Moers an...
10/05/2026

DEFENDANT FOUND GUILTY IN STORAGE UNIT BURGLARY INVOLVING FI****MS

VANDERBURGH COUNTY, Ind. — Prosecutor Diana Moers announces that on September 29, 2026, after a two-day jury trial, the jury found Ryan Carnahan guilty of: Burglary, a Level 5 felony; Theft – Value of Property $750-$50,000, a Level 6 felony; and, Theft with Prior Unrelated Conviction, a Level 6 felony, enhanced from a misdemeanor because of prior theft conviction. The Honorable Magistrate Judge Ryan C. Reed of the Vanderburgh County Circuit Court presided.

On June 30, 2025, an Evansville Police Department Officer was dispatched to Lighthouse Storage at 4405 N. Green River Road for a burglary of a storage unit.

Investigators determined that on June 27, 2025, a suspect entered Lighthouse Storage by following another vehicle through the facility’s access gate and tampering with the gate sensor. Security footage showed the suspect entering a storage unit belonging to Gregory Peete and removing property before leaving the facility in a white Toyota Avalon with a sunroof and missing the right rear hubcap. Approximately three hours later an orange Dodge Nitro with a trailer ball hitch, arrived at the facility. Two individuals entered Peete’s unit and removed a large safe and other property. Peete reported approximately $12,368 in stolen items, including a safe, five fi****ms, related equipment and a canopy with carrying case.

The investigation included extensive review of surveillance footage, Flock camera data, vehicle records and interviews. Investigators determined the vehicles were connected to Ryan Carnahan and Matthew Walls. Additional evidence showed that the stolen gun safe was cut apart and transported to a scrap facility in August 2025 where it was sold for scrap. Search warrants executed at the suspects’ residences and vehicles resulted in the recovery of remnants of the stolen safe and tools believed to have been used to cut it. During subsequent interviews, both Carnahan and Walls acknowledged their involvement in removing the safe, although their accounts differed regarding what they knew about its contents.

At trial, the prosecution presented testimony from the victim, Lighthouse Storage employees, investigators, and the co-defendant, along with surveillance footage, photographs, vehicle records, and recorded statements. The evidence provided the jury with a clear picture of the defendants’ involvement and corroborated the State’s case.

Deputy Prosecutor Keaton Maurer did an excellent job at trial, effectively bringing together the evidence and presenting a compelling case that established the defendant’s guilt. The investigation and successful prosecution were made possible through the diligent work of EPD Detective N. Hackworth and Officer J. Rodriguez. Additional support from Prosecutor’s Office staff L. Deutsch, M. Richardville and J. Pollack was instrumental throughout the case.

The sentencing hearing is set for October 22, 2026. The defendant faces 1 to 6 years, enhanced by a term of 3 to 6 years on the habitual offender enhancement, for a total range of 4 to 12 years.

ABOUT THE OFFICE OF THE VANDERBURGH COUNTY PROSECUTOR

The mission of the Vanderburgh County Office of the Prosecuting Attorney is to effectively and efficiently represent the State of Indiana in criminal court proceedings; maintain a fair and diligent pursuit of justice; invest in technology and training opportunities to fuel an innovative approach to prosecution; deepen partnerships and collaboration with law enforcement agencies; invest in community endeavors that work to better the circumstances of crime victims; partner with organizations who are working to combat crime and/or provide services to crime victims; and continue to protect, serve, and advocate for the citizens of Vanderburgh County.

Prosecutor Diana L. Moers was elected to the Office in 2022.

Prior to being elected, Diana was a trial attorney with over 15 years of experience. She supervised a large section of trial attorneys in state and federal courts, and is an experienced prosecutor for domestic violence, white collar crime cases, and aggravated child abuse cases. Victims of violent crimes can rest assured they have an experienced fighter in their corner.

BURGLAR WHO PREYED ON HOMES OF THOSE WHO RECENTLY PASSED CONVICTED BY JURY VANDERBURGH COUNTY, Ind. — Prosecutor Diana M...
09/28/2026

BURGLAR WHO PREYED ON HOMES OF THOSE WHO RECENTLY PASSED CONVICTED BY JURY

VANDERBURGH COUNTY, Ind. — Prosecutor Diana Moers announces that on September 24, 2026, a jury found Griffin Williams guilty of burglary of a dwelling, a Level 4 felony. The Honorable Magistrate Judge Ryan C. Reed of the Vanderburgh County Circuit Court presided.

On July 29, 2024, EPD officers were called to 1220 S. Cullen Avenue for a home invasion in progress. The home belonged to a woman who passed away on July 16, less than two weeks prior to the burglary. The daughter of the deceased last checked on the home on July 24 and made sure the locks were secure.

A lawncare worker noticed the defendant leaving the house through the side door. He immediately became suspicious and called dispatch. Officers located the defendant on the property. There were signs of forced entry, including a cut lock, screws removed from the lock attachment plate, and pry marks. The defendant’s 2004 black Jeep Liberty was in the driveway. Inside the Jeep was a blue urn containing the ashes of the homeowner’s deceased dog, two personalized notepads with the homeowner’s name on them, three personalized stamp sleeves, and two pairs of bolt cutters. The defendant was unable to flee the scene because she could not start the car and failed to successfully use a screwdriver to bypass the ignition.

At trial, the prosecution presented evidence that the defendant searched the local obituaries that very morning to target a home of the recently deceased. Her DNA was found on the bolt cutters in the Jeep, despite her statement at the scene that she had never touched them. The jury returned with a guilty verdict soon after entering deliberation.

Deputy prosecutors Erik Bryant and Grant Barnett did an excellent job at trial tying together all of the evidence to demonstrate the defendant’s guilt. Investigators who were critical in the prosecution and conviction included EPD Detective D. Powers and Officer Z. Henderson. Prosecutor’s Office staff who assisted included G. Shots, T. Smith, and J. Savage.

Prosecutor Moers had the following statement: “Unfortunately, families of those who pass away are vulnerable to being targeted by people like this Defendant. Those in our society who prey on grieving families should be held accountable and I am proud of my office and the Evansville Police Department for doing just that. The Vanderburgh County digital forensics unit in my office provided critical insight into the truth of this case—that this Defendant was actively seeking to take the belongings of someone who had passed away. I urge the community to please be diligent and watch over friends and families of those experiencing loss; it is because of this diligent lawncare worker that this criminal was apprehended and her scheme was stopped.”

The sentencing hearing is set for October 16, 2026, in front of the Honorable Magistrate Judge Ryan C. Reed of the Vanderburgh County Circuit Court. The defendant faces a possible sentence of 2 to 12 years for the Level 4 burglary.

ABOUT THE OFFICE OF THE VANDERBURGH COUNTY PROSECUTOR

The mission of the Vanderburgh County Office of the Prosecuting Attorney is to effectively and efficiently represent the State of Indiana in criminal court proceedings; maintain a fair and diligent pursuit of justice; invest in technology and training opportunities to fuel an innovative approach to prosecution; deepen partnerships and collaboration with law enforcement agencies; invest in community endeavors that work to better the circumstances of crime victims; partner with organizations who are working to combat crime and/or provide services to crime victims; and continue to protect, serve, and advocate for the citizens of Vanderburgh County.

Prosecutor Diana L. Moers was elected to the Office in 2022.
Prior to being elected, Diana was a trial attorney with over 15 years of experience. She supervised a large section of trial attorneys in state and federal courts, and is an experienced prosecutor for domestic violence, white collar crime cases, and aggravated child abuse cases. Victims of violent crimes can rest assured they have an experienced fighter in their corner.

My office is always happy to support the Southwestern Indiana Su***de Prevention Coalition by helping to sponsor their a...
09/12/2026

My office is always happy to support the Southwestern Indiana Su***de Prevention Coalition by helping to sponsor their annual su***de awareness walk. This well-attended event provides meaningful support and resources for those affected by su***de. You are not alone!

đź’śLocal Crisis Line (812) 422-1100
đź’śNational Crisis Line 988 - text or call!

Indiana Southwest Behavioral
414 S.E. Fourth Street, Downtown Evansville

For medical emergencies, please call 911

đźš” Another great evening with two of our investigators Daren and Tony at National Night Out! We always enjoy talking to t...
08/05/2026

đźš” Another great evening with two of our investigators Daren and Tony at National Night Out! We always enjoy talking to the public and seeing all of the kids excited about our law enforcement and advocacy community who work together to keep us safe! đźš’

⚖️ We truly appreciate the hard work of our Evansville Fire Department, Vanderburgh County Sheriff's Office, Evansville Police Department, Holly's House, Indiana State Police Evansville District, Attorney General Todd Rokita, Evansville Animal Care & Control (Official), Vanderburgh County Health Department and others who we work with regularly on a range of duties including trial work, appeals, victim advocacy, animal advocacy, child safety and community outreach. We have the best community! ⚖️

07/16/2026

SHARE YOUR STORY

We are conducting a two-part study to learn more about the experiences of survivors of intimate partner violence or domestic violence. The first part of the study consists of a series of general questions about your life experiences. You can skip any questions in the survey or exit the survey at any time. If you choose to only complete the first part of the study, your data will remain anonymous. To learn more, click the Qualtrics link
below:

https://usisurvey.az1.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_79z6NkibSLfYPDo

In part two of the study, we will conduct interviews that are expected to last between 20 minutes to 1 hour over Zoom or on the phone. All participants who complete the interview will receive a $20 electronic gift card to the location of their choosing.

Participants must complete part 1 to participate in part 2. If you have any questions or would like to learn more about the study, please contact Dr. Taylor Petty ([email protected]).

PROSECUTOR REQUESTED 16 YEARS PRISON TIME IMPOSED ON KASHIA BLANKS FOR CAUSING PERMANENT BRAIN DAMAGE TO 2-YEAR-OLD GIRL...
06/26/2026

PROSECUTOR REQUESTED 16 YEARS PRISON TIME IMPOSED ON KASHIA BLANKS FOR CAUSING PERMANENT BRAIN DAMAGE TO 2-YEAR-OLD GIRL

VANDERBURGH COUNTY, Ind. — Prosecutor Diana Moers issues this statement in response to recent media coverage of the sentence imposed on Kashia Blanks for neglect resulting in permanent brain damage to a two-year-old girl.

At the sentencing hearing on June 24, 2026, my office asked the Court to impose a sentence of 16 years executed fully at the Indiana Department of Correction. The severity of the sentence is well-warranted: the board-certified medical professionals testified at trial that the brain damage was caused by abusive head trauma, was non-accidental, and was consistent with the two-year-old being thrown or slammed down on a soft surface. They rejected the theory posited by defense that a 4-year-old autistic child had pushed the two-year-old down the stairs.

The jury came back with a guilty verdict in less than 2 hours, finding that the defendant committed Level 3 felony neglect of a dependent.

The brain damage to the two-year-old is overwhelming and permanent. The now-six-year-old child cannot talk or walk. She suffers from constant seizures and had to have a vagus nerve stimulator implanted to control them. At any point, a large-enough seizure could end her life. The child’s life expectancy has been greatly shortened. She favors the left side, meaning the right side of her body is weakened and cannot be easily moved. She must attend weekly physical, speech, and other therapeutic sessions, possibly for life.

The victim in this case—like many other child victims—is not able to speak on their own behalf; it is the sacred and heavy responsibility of my office to hold their abusers accountable and seek an appropriately weighty punishment for their actions. While the sentence imposed on Kashia Blanks did not reach that level, my office will continue to vigorously prosecute those who would harm children and achieve justice for the most vulnerable in our community.

PROLIFIC ANIMAL ABUSER SHAYNA BURKO GETS MORE PRISON TIME ​VANDERBURGH COUNTY, Ind. — Prosecutor Diana Moers announces t...
06/09/2026

PROLIFIC ANIMAL ABUSER SHAYNA BURKO GETS MORE PRISON TIME

​VANDERBURGH COUNTY, Ind. — Prosecutor Diana Moers announces that on Tuesday, June 9, the Honorable Magistrate Judge Ryan C. Reed of the Vanderburgh Circuit Court revoked the probation of Shayna Faye Burko and ordered her to serve time in prison for her crimes against animals.

The decision was made during a hearing on Tuesday, where Burko appeared for a case in which she was charged and convicted of seven Level 6 Felony counts of cruelty to animals.

Burko was previously sentenced to serve two years of probation in this case, but Tuesday’s hearing to revoke her probation came about after she recently pled guilty to several counts of animal cruelty in a separate case Warrick County, Indiana. In her recent case in Warrick County, Burko was also sentenced to serve 4 years in prison.

During Tuesday’s hearing, Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Keaton Maurer argued that the conditions of Burko’s probation included possessing no animals, aside from a service animal if applicable. DPA Maurer pointed out Burko’s blatant disregard for that condition and her pattern of animal abuse, listing the numerous animals that suffered at Burko’s hands in the Warrick County case.

After hearing the State’s arguments, Judge Reed revoked Burko’s prior sentence of 2 years’ probation and instead ordered her to serve 2 years at the Indiana Department of Correction. At the time of Burko’s original sentencing in 2023, the State requested she receive the maximum executed sentence of 4 years in prison.

Burko was arrested in 2022 after leaving several dogs in a home on Mooring Road to suffer and die. The rooms of the home were filled with urine and f***s. In addition to a deceased German Shepard, officers found a detached dog head and limb inside the home. Of the dogs that survived the horrific abuse, several were malnourished.

​Burko’s case is one of several that motivated Prosecutor Moers to fight for stricter punishments for animal abusers and stronger protections for animals in our state. Prosecutor Moers collaborated with Representative Wendy McNamara on House Bill 1165, which was recently signed into law by Gov. Mike Braun. During her time in Indianapolis testifying in support of the bill, Prosecutor Moers pointed to several animal cruelty cases that justified the new protective measures, including Burko’s.

Following Tuesday’s hearing, Prosecutor Moers said: “It is a well-studied fact that animal abusers and hoarders are often repeat offenders and pose a serious threat to our society by their propensity to commit violent and other crimes. This is why I worked with Rep. Wendy McNamara to change the law in Indiana and increase the penalties for animal neglect and hoarding situations, so we don’t have to wait for defendants to hoard, harm and neglect animals repeatedly before they see the inside of a prison. I am glad to see this prolific animal abuser and hoarder finally get the prison time she deserves—which was the maximum amount allowable under the law—and that she will no longer have access to animals.

Animal cases are difficult to prosecute because the victims cannot speak. I commend our animal rescue community who has shown up for these animals and remained a voice and advocate to the defenseless. I also thank our law enforcement at animal control and the Evansville Police Department Humane Unit and especially the Prosecution Team in Warrick County including Prosecutor Mike Perry and John Schaefer who fought hard to make sure Shana Burko received a four-year sentence before being re-sentenced on her case in Vanderburgh County.

These cases require careful investigation, time, and expertise to successfully prosecute. I encourage Vanderburgh County residents to remain vigilant and if they suspect animal abuse or neglect—please call 911. Our Evansville Police and Sheriff Departments as well as animal control are trained to identify animal abuse and neglect and also to identify those who might need resources to properly take care of their animals. If animals are being abused and neglected, other vulnerable people are also at risk such as children, the sick, and the elderly.

If you find yourself unable to care for animals you have, please reach out for help! Abandoning and neglecting animals is not only cruel but carries with it criminal penalties which can be avoided.”

Address

1 NW Martin Luther King, Jr, Boulevard, Civic Center Complex/Room 108
Evansville, IN
47708

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 4:30pm
Tuesday 8am - 4:30pm
Wednesday 8am - 4:30pm
Thursday 8am - 4:30pm
Friday 8am - 4:30pm
Saturday 8am - 4pm
Sunday 12am - 11pm

Telephone

+18124355150

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Vanderburgh County Prosecutor's Office posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share

Nearby government services