11/05/2026
Dear Members of the Indiana Parole Board,
As the Prosecuting Attorney for the First Judicial Circuit of the State of Indiana which is comprised of Vanderbugh County, I stand in opposition to the clemency request of Jeffery Weisheit and ask that you recommend the death penalty sentence be imposed on November 5, 2026, as set by Order of the Indiana Supreme Court.
The board can consider certain factors at this clemency hearing and the ones I am here to highlight are: the nature and circumstances of the offense and what’s in the best interests of society. I intend to add brief remarks regarding the affect of this case on society—specifically the people of Vanderburgh County and also regarding Caleb and Alyssa Lynch and their mother, Lisa Lynch.
To be clear, I was not in the prosecutor’s office when this crime occurred but this case is still very alive in our community, to our first responders, to the courts, and in the halls of my office. I commend all of those who responded that day and who were involved in carrying this case through to the finish. Thank you to Deputy Attorneys General Angela Sanchez, the Chief Counsel for Appeals at the Attorney General’s Office and Tyler Banks, Section Chief for Capital Litigation at the Attorney Generals Office, and their colleagues, for carrying this case through to the finish.
Vanderburgh County
The Defendant left a lasting negative impact on Vanderburgh County’s first responders and citizens. This trial was moved to a different county in partial recognition that the heinous crime commited by Weisheit and its impact on the community was so vast that it hindered the abiltity to find a jury of his peers in Vanderburgh County to hear it. Vanderburgh County was, and still is, consumed by news of the horrible murders of two completely innocent children and left with imagining the pain and grief felt by their mother Lisa Lynch—who not only lost her two children but also her home and belongings to the fire set by Weisheit. Anyone familiar with this case will never forget the facts of what Jeffrey Weisheit did to five-year-old Caleb and eight-year-old Alyssa Lynch, nevertheless, it is important to state it with these remarks. The Indiana Supreme Court summarizes the heinous actions of Weisheit in their August 28,2026, Order Setting Ex*****on Date.
Five-year-old Caleb Lynch and eight-year-old Alyssa Lynch were left in Weisheit’s care whle their mother worked. After becoming irate at Caleb, Weisheit shoved a washcloth into his mouth which was secured with duct tape, Weisheit then hog-tied the child using duct tape, put a railroad flare into his underwear and one under his body and set him on fire on a mattress. Caleb was burned beyond recognition but fire officials testfied that he was alive while his left thigh was burnt by the railroad flare -eventually the mattress he was laying on caught fire and he suffocated. At trial, when Weisheit was cross examined about the severe burns to Caleb’s leg he said: “things happen.” Eight-year-old Alyssa Lynch was found by fire personnel in a closet—over 90% of her body was charred black and the pathologist testified that she may have burned while she was still alive or as she asphyxiated from the soot and smoke inhallation.
Vanderburgh County first responders, court personnel, and citizens will never forget these horrific facts which they are forced to discover and re-live each time Jeffrey Weisheit files a brief or request. For the victims’ families and first responders who lived this horrific experience, the effects of the endless litigation are even more severe. The proceedings regarding Weisheit, who was charged in 2010 and convicted in 2013 after a jury trial, have been significant—he has sought post conviction relief by way of direct and post-conviction appeals and habeaus petitions in the State and Federal Courts.
We can’t imagine what the last thoughts of those sweet children must have been- yet the citizens of Vanderburgh County, and many other parts of the State and even country, undoubtedly ask themselves this question when they read about the facts of this case. We are all worse off for experiencing this case. We can only pray that God intervened for Caleb and Alyssa quickly and gave them peace from their suffering. Weisheit was the last person they saw- someone who was in charge of taking care of them. Now, our state and community has spent over a decade concerned with the rights, preferences and concerns of Jeffery Weisheit., the prosecutors first had to prepare the case and prove him guilty beyond a reasonable doubt—the highest burden in the law. Everyone involved had to prepare for years and relive that horrible day as we are right now. When the trial is done, the Defendant is afforded numerous appeals, hearings, considerations, discussions and medical examinations—even up until days before this hearing the Defendant has requested more medical exams for something that was aleady addressed in his sentencing at the trial court—and so we see his name in the paper again. The law swings heavily in favor of Defendants. It seems nearly impossible for a death sentence to be carried out and, on the way there, it has cost the State hundreds of thousands of dollars and hundreds if not thousands of hours of collective work from the courts, probation, medical staff, and attorneys.
Jeffrey Weisheit has hurt our society, degraded the sanctity of human life, desecrated two young children, and exposed many in Vanderburgh County to an unimaginable horror that they will live with forever in some way. I hope that on November 5, 2026 Weisheit’s requests (which cause headlines to bring up his name and the collective trauma in our county repeatedly) can come to an end when his ex*****on is carried out.
Caleb and Alyssa Lynch
As has been the case for over a decade, Jeffrey Weisheit’s name is said over and over, and his rights and wishes considered, while the memories of victims are cut short. I want to share some final thoughts about Alyssa and Caleb Lynch from the trial transcript. They would be young adults today but the Defendant’s actions have frozen them in time as small children.
I want to share memories of them. In June of 2013, teachers of Alyssa and Caleb were called to testify at the Defendant’s trial. Alyssa’s elementary school teacher Mrs. Hamilton described Alyssa as soft spoken, polite, and mannerly – she had fun on the playground at recess but, when it came time for it, she was in her seat and ready to learn. When Mrs. Hamilton was asked about Alyssa, she said she wished she had ten children just like her. Caleb’s pre-school teacher Mrs. Gomez described Caleb when he was in her pre-school class in 2010: He loved playing as any five year old does and was very gregarious and talkative. Mrs. Gomez said Caleb loved making little noises and joked that he must have had a job as a ventriloquist at some point- because he would make the noises but you didn’t know where they were coming from. She said the word that comes to mind when she thinks
of him is loving—he was an extremely loving little boy.
Some will argue that life in prison is the way to handle this case but the only way to ensure justice and put an end to the endless collective trauma which is relived by all with each of the Defendant’s endless filings and requests is to put an end to Weisheit’s voice once and for all. Unlike Caleb and Alyssa, the children he burned alive and their mother (who lost everything and must live with that unbearable pain), he had a choice that day and has been given extensive consideration and due process. The death penalty was the sentence recommended by the jury, reviewed by our courts, and so it is justice.
Every person should be afforded the full protections of the United States Constitution and the due process it brings—this is truly what makes America the best country in the world.
Jeffrey Weisheit has exhausted his constitutional protections and so the answer is final—the death penalty should be imposed. May God have mercy.
Sincerely,
Diana L. Moers
Prosecuting Attorney, First Judicial Circuit
Vanderburgh County, Indiana