10/16/2026
Last night, the Board of Supervisors voted 3-2 to grant Final Approval to the Indiana Trails Planned Residential Development (PRD). Sarah Hertweck, Township Supervisor, and I cast the dissenting No votes against approval. By now, most Indiana Township residents have driven down Dorseyville or Fox Chapel Roads and seen the scar in the landscape that will soon be the site of 84 housing units. The destruction and disruption caused by grading the Indiana Trails site made a mockery of the Board Majority's claim that PRDs preserve greenspace and promote development harmonious with the surrounding community. Nevertheless, the Board Majority voted to approve Indiana Trails, relying on the Solicitor's advice that, in the normal PRD process, Final Approval must be given if the final plan does not significantly change from the tentative plan previously given Tentative Approval.
The problem is, Indiana Trails has gone through anything but the normal PRD process. This piece of land has been in litigation for nearly a decade, as our citizens have challenged the Board of Supervisors' PRD approval in court. All the while, the Township has spent taxpayer money on legal fees to fight alongside the developer in the lawsuits. In making our determination last night, the "tentative plan" that we had to compare to the "final plan" was not the same plan the Board of Supervisors approved in 2023; it was a significantly different plan resulting from a settlement between the developer and the citizens who brought the lawsuit. This new plan, created by this settlement, reduced total units from 100 to 84, but it also removed a significant number of trees that would have protected residents near Fox Chapel Road from negative impacts they have experienced, such as sawdust pollution and excessive runoff. In many ways, this court-approved settlement plan preserves even less greenspace and is less harmonious with the surrounding community than the plan approved in 2023. The Board was given a Consent Order to approve the terms of this settlement, but the Court never provided us with a legal justification explaining how this settlement plan conforms to the PRD law in place in 2023, when Indiana Trails came before the Board of Supervisors. I voted NO on Final Approval last night because the Court failed to provide any explanation of how the new settlement plan meets the standards our law required for PRD approval.
Even if we accept the Board Majority's explanation that they had no choice but to grant Final Approval to Indiana Trails, we must not accept this explanation as an excuse for the destruction caused by overdevelopment in Indiana Township. We, the Board of Supervisors, have the power to repeal the PRD Article from our Zoning Code. Two months ago, Supervisor Hertweck and I made a motion to begin the process of eliminating the PRD Article from our code, but we were voted down 3-2. Make no mistake, responsibility for the impact of all future PRD proposals falls directly upon Supervisors Jorgensen, Kaan, and Krally for failing to close the door on PRDs when they had the chance. They chose to have "no choice" but to approve PRDs; they used their power to make themselves powerless against the aggression of outside developers. The future of Indiana Township and the Fox Chapel School District is at risk until at least one of the other three supervisors joins me, Sarah, and the vast majority of Indiana Township residents in our desire to pause PRD development at least until our long-overdue Comprehensive Plan is complete. If you are represented by Supervisor Jorgensen, Kaan, or Krally, please reach out and let them know that you want them to protect our community and eliminate the PRD Article from the Zoning Code before it is too late.