Labor True Believers, Political Analysis and Satire

Directions

Labor True Believers, Political Analysis and Satire A Page for Labor supporters who believe in the Labor Party and are dedicated to supporting its Leader Anthony Albanese.

11/11/2026

FORMER CFMEU BOSS JOHN SETKA EXPELLED AMID $3.3 MILLION MISAPPROPRIATION ALLEGATIONS

Former Victorian construction union boss John Setka has been expelled from the CFMEU for five years, the maximum period permitted under union rules, as administrators pursue allegations that millions of dollars were diverted from union-related activities.

CFMEU administrator Michael Crosby alleges approximately $3.3 million generated through construction-site vending machines and merchandise sales was channelled into companies associated with Setka rather than benefiting union members.

Crosby says Setka failed to respond to the allegations and has pledged to pursue recovery of the money. Setka has previously denied wrongdoing in relation to the fund. The allegations of misappropriation have not been established in criminal proceedings.

UNION ATTEMPTS TO REBUILD

Setka led the Victorian branch for 12 years before resigning in July 2024 following investigations into alleged corruption, intimidation and organised crime infiltration.

The federal government subsequently placed the CFMEU’s construction division into administration. Since then, administrators have removed or replaced numerous officials in an effort to restore lawful governance and public confidence.

Setka’s expulsion formally ends his membership of the organisation he once dominated.

SEPARATE COURT PROCEEDINGS

The decision follows Setka’s admission in the Federal Court last week that he breached workplace laws by attempting to pressure the AFL into dismissing its head of officiating, Stephen McBurney.

McBurney previously headed the Australian Building and Construction Commission, which had pursued legal action against the CFMEU.
Setka threatened disruption to AFL construction projects unless McBurney was removed.

The court has yet to determine penalties.

Setka also faces separate criminal charges concerning alleged threats and harassment directed at union administrators. Those charges remain allegations.

BROADER CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY SCRUTINY

The expulsion comes as Victoria’s royal commission investigates alleged corruption and improper influence on major taxpayer-funded infrastructure projects.

Evidence before the inquiry has raised questions about union pressure on contractors, labour-hire arrangements and construction costs. The commission has not yet delivered its findings.

Crosby says the union’s administration is intended to restore an organisation capable of representing construction workers without intimidation, corruption or criminal influence.

The challenge now is to ensure that the misconduct alleged against former officials does not overshadow the legitimate role of unions in protecting workers’ wages, conditions and safety.

— The National Herald

11/11/2026

WHEN THE COST OF SPEAKING OUT BECOMES A WEAPON

A coalition of 35 Australian civil society organisations is calling for new federal laws to prevent wealthy companies and powerful individuals from using expensive legal proceedings to silence critics.

The Australian Democracy Network’s Stop the SLAPP alliance has joined forces with internationally recognised human rights lawyer Jennifer Robinson to campaign for stronger protections.

SLAPP stands for Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation.

These lawsuits can involve defamation or other legal claims brought against journalists, whistleblowers, environmental campaigners, abuse survivors and community advocates.

The concern is that even when a case ultimately fails, the financial burden of defending it can intimidate people into silence.

WHY AUSTRALIA NEEDS REFORM

Robinson, who represented Amber Heard in the British defamation proceedings involving Johnny Depp and a UK newspaper, says Australia is falling behind other democracies in protecting public-interest speech. She is particularly concerned about defamation proceedings used to discourage women from reporting abuse.

The alliance wants federal legislation allowing courts to identify and dismiss abusive lawsuits early, before defendants face potentially devastating legal bills. Its proposals include placing the burden on claimants to demonstrate why their proceedings should not be classified as SLAPP actions.

Alliance convenor Aish Cowgill warns that wealthy organisations can use their financial resources to overwhelm ordinary people, regardless of the eventual legal outcome.

WOODSIDE CASE HIGHLIGHTS CONCERNS

The alliance points to legal action involving energy company Woodside and climate protesters in Western Australia. Woodside sought information identifying protesters following an incident at its Perth headquarters in 2023.

The WA Supreme Court dismissed the application, observing that it formed part of the company’s broader efforts to discourage protests against its projects. The alliance cites the case as an example of why stronger legal safeguards are needed.

Similar anti-SLAPP protections have been introduced or advanced in jurisdictions including the European Union, Ireland and parts of the United States.

PROTECTING SPEECH WITHOUT REMOVING LEGAL RIGHTS

The proposed reforms would not mean that every defamation or other civil claim against a critic was illegitimate. People and businesses must retain access to courts to protect their lawful interests and reputations.

The challenge is identifying proceedings primarily intended to intimidate, punish or suppress legitimate public participation.
Without effective safeguards, the right to speak freely can become meaningless for those unable to afford years of litigation.

As Robinson asks: “What does free speech mean if you can’t afford to defend it?”

— The National Herald

11/11/2026

A very important article.
_______

Jillian Segal’s school curriculum changes will backfire

By Jeff Loewenstein

Australian kids will learn ‘Jewish history‘ starting in 2027, the education minister has said

The Israel lobby demands, and the government folds. This is the current mode of governance in Australia, as reflected by the education minister’s decision last week to change the school curriculum from 2027 to “strengthen the teaching of … antisemitism” – a change that should alarm parents of school-aged children.

The federal education minister, Jason Clare, was provided a pressure-free platform on ABC Radio National last week to announce that students will gain a “more thorough teaching of the Holocaust … [and] Jewish history, as well as the contribution that Jewish Australians have made to Australia”.

Clare referenced the “Antisemitism Education Taskforce” as the brains behind “these changes to the curriculum that was presented to ministers”.

The idea was initially born out of Jillian Segal’s widely-condemned antisemitism plan, released in July 2025, which called for “embed[ding] Holocaust and antisemitism education … in national and state school curricula”. The taskforce, which is headed by pro-Israel businessman David Gonski and includes Segal, is overseeing the ex*****on of the plan with regards to education.

Parents should be horrified to learn that their children will be taught the matters outlined by Clare, in a country which prides itself as being religiously and ethnically diverse, non-denominational (see Section 116 of our Constitution) and with almost 10 million Australians reported as having no religion.

Jews, of whom there are about 120,000 in Australia – including the writer and many others who oppose the Israel lobby’s clear intent to manipulate our education system – will be appalled to see Jews deemed worthy of ‘special treatment’ in educating Australia’s children.

The singling out of Jewish Australians with respect to the ‘contribution’ (whatever that might mean) they have made to Australia does not make Jews any ‘safer’. It clearly tells the other 99 per cent of the country that one group sits above all others. Forget about First Nations and immigrants of different ethnic, cultural or religious backgrounds being recognised as valuable contributors to Australia.

Segal’s intent and plan is patently clear. Her aim is not to address antisemitism, let alone the social cohesion which the Royal Commission has been charged to address. Her agenda, and that of the Israel lobby, is to silence criticism of Israel. Why else push the adoption of the IHRA definition of what constitutes antisemitism – which its author just said has been poisoned to the point of useless?

When Segal says that it is okay to criticise Israel, she speaks with a forked tongue. It would be more apt to retitle Segal’s role from ‘Special Envoy to Combat Antisemitism’ to ‘thought policewoman’, as this is precisely how she and her unelected, taxpayer-funded office are operating.

But attempts by Segal and the Israel lobby to indoctrinate Australians into forging a pro-Israel outlook from birth will fail. To the contrary, it will potentially cause real antisemitism by instilling in the minds of Australians that one, small group deserves a privileged status. This breeds resentment, not sympathy.

Is Segal blind to the fact that 79 per cent of Australians do not look upon Israel favourably? Does she truly think manipulating the education system will undo the damage? Surely those who understand the gravity of a genocide know the long-lasting endurance of such crimes in the memories of those who bore witness – and hundreds of millions did, on their phones, daily.

Segal and her supporters will not be able to erase what people have seen Israel do in Gaza. What Zionism is all about in action – death, destruction, injury, starvation, cruelty and colonialism – has been exposed for the world to see.

Australians will not accept what Segal is proposing. Instead, what is being revealed to them is the insidious workings of the Israel lobby as part of Israel’s global PR campaign – and it’s making many in this country, Left and Right, uncomfortable.

One need only look to the recent US elections to see how Israel is now on the nose. The influence of the Israel lobby and Netanyahu in US politics has been called out like never before. Not even tens of millions of dollars poured into pro-Israel candidates (or servants) by AIPAC could save them from defeat. Add to that the large number of American Jews now siding with the Palestinians over Israel.

That Clare, federal and state governments and mainstream journalists in this country still speak of criticism of Israel as being antisemitic begs one to ask: what world are these people living on? Can they not see that the elections in our supposed ‘greatest ally’ have just shattered these gaslighting talking points?

Israel – despite the tireless work of its lobbyists from Woollahra and Caulfield to Washington and New York – has lost the narrative.

All the desperate attempts to skew the narrative have failed. Nothing is working. Not the purchasing of nearly every major media, film and TV production company in the US. Not the purchasing of TikTok. Not strong-arming weak and incompetent western governments into criminalising “hate speech” and labelling protests as “terrorist” activity. Not militarised police forces sent to beat up protesters. Not the front-page spreads in mainstream papers – which fewer people are reading.

And changing our school curriculum won’t solve that palpable and justified anger towards Israel – it will intensify it.

Note - Jeffrey was a member of the Victorian Bar and a one-time Chairman of the Anti-Defamation Commission and member of the Jewish Community Council of Victoria

11/11/2026

THE AMERICAN PEOPLE ARE STILL WAITING, DONALD!

Donald Trump has never been short of promises, particularly when it comes to handing out money to the American people. Unfortunately, when it comes to delivering on those promises, the cheques seem to be getting lost in the mail.

First came the promise of a $2,000 tariff dividend for ordinary Americans, supposedly funded by the billions collected through his administration's new tariffs. That was back in November 2025. More than a year later, Americans are still waiting.

Then came an even bigger promise: a $5,000 Trump Dividend, dangled in the lead-up to the 2026 midterm elections, with Trump suggesting Americans would receive the money if Republicans retained control of Congress.

There is just one rather inconvenient problem: the numbers simply don't add up.

Handing $5,000 to approximately 245 million American adults would cost somewhere in the region of $1.2 trillion. Yet annual tariff collections amount to only a fraction of that figure. Even if every dollar collected through tariffs went towards these payments, the government would still be facing an enormous shortfall.

And let's not forget that tariffs are not some magical pot of money belonging to Donald Trump. They are taxes on imported goods, with much of the cost ultimately passed on to American businesses and consumers through higher prices.

There have been smaller, targeted payments, including reported $500 ACA refunds and $90 Medicare payments, but these are hardly the sweeping financial windfalls Trump has been advertising.

The reality is that Americans are dealing with the cost of living, expensive groceries, housing pressures and economic uncertainty. They deserve more than political promises, election slogans and grand announcements designed to generate headlines.

If Donald Trump wants to take credit for putting money into the pockets of ordinary Americans, perhaps he should start by actually putting the money there.

The American people are not asking for another campaign speech. They are asking for the money they were promised.

Donald Trump has made the promises. Now it's time to keep them.

Because when it comes to political promises, eventually the voters expect delivery, not another sales pitch.

THE NATIONAL HERALD

Promises are easy. Delivering is what counts.

11/11/2026

RACING COMMUNITY MOURNS DEATH OF YOUNG JOCKEY IZZY NEALE, 22

Australian racing is mourning the death of promising apprentice jockey Izzy Neale, who died after suffering severe injuries in a race fall in regional New South Wales.

The 22-year-old was riding Marnoo in the Warren Shire Cotton Cup on Sunday when her horse fell approaching the home straight, about 400 metres from the finish.

Neale suffered serious head injuries and was airlifted unconscious to Dubbo Hospital, where she died on Tuesday surrounded by family and friends.

In a heartbreaking statement, her family described their beloved Izzy as someone whose passion for horses began almost before she could walk.

That lifelong love had developed into a promising professional racing career, during which she rode 88 winners.

A FINAL GIFT TO OTHERS

Amid their grief, Neale’s family confirmed that she would become an organ donor, offering others the chance of life.

They said the decision brought some comfort during their devastating loss.

The family thanked medical staff, Racing NSW, the NSW Jockeys Association and the many people who had offered kindness and support.

Tributes have flowed from across the racing community.

Trainer Richard Freedman said words were inadequate to express the loss, while fellow trainer John Thompson described Neale as a beautiful young woman whose death had left the world poorer.

RACING COMMUNITY UNITED IN GRIEF

The accident also involved jockey Diego Montes de Oca, who was dislodged from his horse, Shadow Dane. He sustained soft-tissue injuries to his left foot and was subsequently discharged from hospital.

Tragically, Neale’s mount, six-year-old Marnoo, suffered a severe foreleg injury and was euthanased.

The final race at Warren was abandoned, and Monday’s meeting at Scone was postponed as the racing community came to terms with the tragedy.

Neale’s death is a devastating reminder of the dangers jockeys face in a sport to which they dedicate their lives.

For her family, friends and colleagues, however, she will be remembered above all for her love of horses, her warmth and the promising life cut tragically short.

Her family’s final tribute was simple:

“Izzy was dearly loved and will forever be in our hearts.”

— The National Herald

11/11/2026

NETANYAHU ATTACKS ARAB LAWMAKERS AS OPPONENTS MOVE TO TAKE CONTROL OF ISRAEL’S PARLIAMENT

Israel’s newly elected parliament has opened amid bitter political divisions, with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu attacking the prospect of Arab parties helping form a new government as his opponents move to take control of the Knesset.

The confrontation followed Tuesday’s swearing-in of Israel’s 26th Knesset, where Netanyahu accused Arab lawmakers of supporting terrorism and opposing the existence of Israel.

His remarks drew an angry response from former military chief Gadi Eisenkot, whose political bloc is seeking to replace Netanyahu’s government. Eisenkot described the speech as “delusional” and “shameful”, declaring Netanyahu unfit to remain in office.

ARAB LAWMAKERS TARGETED

During the ceremony, far-right politician Itamar Ben-Gvir interrupted Joint List leader Yousef Jabareen as he took his parliamentary oath, shouting that he was swearing allegiance to Hamas. Later, Likud lawmakers heckled Arab representatives who left the chamber before Israel’s national anthem.

Netanyahu subsequently warned against forming a government dependent on Arab parties, describing them as supporters of terrorism.

However, United Arab List leader Mansour Abbas rejected that characterisation, emphasising his party’s condemnation of terrorism and support for a negotiated two-state solution.

“We have condemned every act of terror,” Abbas said. He also asserted his party’s right to participate in government.

The controversy raises a fundamental democratic question: while political parties may disagree profoundly, Arab citizens’ elected representatives possess the same parliamentary voting rights as other members of the Knesset.

OPPOSITION MOVES TO REPLACE SPEAKER

Meanwhile, Eisenkot’s Yashar party announced that 61 members of the 120-seat Knesset had signed a request for a vote to replace Speaker Amir Ohana, a Netanyahu ally.

The opposition bloc has nominated Matan Kahana, with the vote scheduled for November 17. The signatures demonstrate sufficient support to initiate the vote, although they do not guarantee Kahana’s election. Arab lawmaker Ahmad Tibi has indicated his faction will support Kahana.

Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich condemned the prospect, arguing that a Speaker elected with Arab lawmakers’ votes would lack legitimacy and describing the Arab parties as Israel’s enemies.

The dispute highlights the central political challenge facing Netanyahu’s opponents: whether parties with substantial ideological differences can cooperate to form an alternative government.

OCTOBER 7 INQUIRY AND JUDICIAL REFORMS

Eisenkot’s party has also introduced proposals to establish a state commission of inquiry into the October 7 attacks, limit prime ministerial terms and repeal controversial judicial overhaul legislation. These proposals could have significant consequences for government accountability and judicial independence.

A parliamentary majority opposed to Netanyahu does not automatically guarantee the formation of a stable government, and another election remains possible if coalition negotiations fail.

QATAR ALLEGATIONS ADD TO CONFRONTATION

Netanyahu also demanded an investigation into allegations that Qatar funded efforts to increase Arab voter turnout. Opposition leader Naftali Bennett responded by raising allegations that advisers in Netanyahu’s own office had received payments to promote Qatari interests.

Both matters remain allegations requiring examination.

The confrontation illustrates the stakes in Israel’s changing political landscape. Beyond the struggle to replace Netanyahu, the incoming parliament faces fundamental questions about democratic representation, government accountability and whether elected Arab lawmakers will be treated as legitimate participants in determining Israel’s political future.

— The National Herald

11/11/2026

𝐍𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧𝐚𝐥 𝐇𝐞𝐫𝐚𝐥𝐝 𝐑𝐞𝐧𝐞𝐰𝐚𝐛𝐥𝐞 𝐔𝐩𝐝𝐚𝐭𝐞
By Sophie Vorrath

New data published by Victoria’s gas distributors as part of mandatory reporting requirements set in place by state Labor in August have turned up some very interesting patterns on residential gas use – namely, that households are using a lot less of the fossil fuel, even if they’re not disconnecting.

The Victorian Energy Future Network (VEFN) has this week shared its analysis of data released under the 2026 Ministerial Order by AusNet, Multinet Gas Networks and Australian Gas Networks (AGN), including never before seen monthly, postcode-level numbers on gas use and connections.

“All three distributors published the same five tables on 28 and 29 October under the Ministerial Order,” the VEFN analysis says. “Together they cover about 2.25 million residential connections, effectively every gas household in Victoria.”

Read more:- https://reneweconomy.com.au/household-gas-use-is-falling-much-faster-than-connections-new-data-shows-as-quiet-quitting-takes-hold/

11/11/2026

NATIONAL HERALD EDITORIAL

NEWS CORP'S OBSESSION WITH ALBANESE: WHERE HAS RESPECT FOR THE OFFICE OF PRIME MINISTER GONE?

There comes a point when Australians have every right to question whether sections of the mainstream media are genuinely interested in holding governments accountable or whether they have become so entrenched in their political preferences that almost everything a government does is viewed through a negative lens.

For many Australians, News Corp has become a subject of that debate.

It is not simply one article, one headline or one particularly aggressive press conference. It is the cumulative effect of years of coverage in which the Albanese Government appears to face an almost relentless barrage of negative commentary, political criticism and personal attacks.

Consider the pattern. When Anthony Albanese travels overseas to represent Australia, the headlines concentrate on his absence from home. When he remains in Australia, criticism turns to what he is doing domestically. When he answers questions from journalists, attention shifts to his temperament, facial expressions and whether he has lost his cool.

Apparently, whatever the Prime Minister does, there is another opportunity to manufacture a political controversy.

But the recent Canberra press conference raises another issue that deserves particular attention: the manner in which the Prime Minister was questioned.

We witnessed journalists putting questions to Albanese in an increasingly aggressive and confrontational manner. There is absolutely nothing wrong with difficult questions. Journalists have a responsibility to challenge the Prime Minister, demand explanations and scrutinise government decisions. That is an essential part of democracy.

However, there is a considerable difference between robust journalism and questioning that appears to have little regard for the office the Prime Minister holds.

Respect for the office of Prime Minister does not mean giving the Prime Minister an easy ride. It means recognising that questioning the nation's elected leader should be conducted with professionalism, courtesy and mutual respect.

The Prime Minister is not required to accept every question without challenge, nor should journalists expect him to remain expressionless while being subjected to repeated confrontational and angry biased questioning. When journalists adopt an aggressive tone, they should not be surprised if the response is equally firm.

Yet what happens afterwards? Rather than examining the nature of the exchange and the conduct of those asking the questions, the commentary turns towards whether Albanese has lost his temper.

It is another opportunity to make the Prime Minister the story rather than examine the issues he was attempting to address.

And where was this same intensity of questioning when Tony Abbott and Scott Morrison occupied the Prime Minister's office? Would the same commentators have devoted so much attention to their demeanour, temperament and responses under pressure? These are reasonable questions about consistency in political journalism, and they deserve examination.

The concern is not that the Prime Minister should be protected from criticism. No politician should be. It is that professional standards and basic courtesy should apply to journalists just as they apply to everyone else.

There is also a much bigger question: does News Corp apply the same standards of scrutiny to Coalition governments as it applies to Labor governments?

The selection of stories, the headlines, the repeated negative commentary and the prominence given to particular political controversies have led many Australians to question whether News Corp approaches its coverage of the Albanese Government with the same impartiality expected of a major national media organisation.

This is not simply a complaint made by Labor politicians. Academic research published in 2024, examining more than 30 million newspaper articles, found evidence of a conservative shift in the political slant of newspapers already owned by News Corp following its 2016 acquisitions. Concerns about media concentration and political influence have also been raised in parliamentary inquiries into media diversity.

News Corp is entitled to publish its editorial opinions, criticise Labor policies and support arguments put forward by the Coalition. But readers are equally entitled to question its editorial priorities, political framing and consistency.

There is an important distinction between factual reporting and political commentary. When negative narratives are repeatedly promoted across headlines, opinion columns and television commentary, the cumulative effect can be to shape public perceptions before readers have had an opportunity to consider the facts.

Look at the Prime Minister's current overseas itinerary. His visit to Türkiye involves Australia's participation in COP31 climate negotiations, followed by important regional engagements in the Philippines and China. These are significant diplomatic, economic and regional security responsibilities.

Of course, the costs and objectives of international travel should be scrutinised. Australians facing mortgage repayments, rising household expenses and cost-of-living pressures are entitled to ask what benefits these visits deliver. But international diplomacy, trade negotiations, regional security and Australia's relationships with important trading partners do not suddenly become unimportant because domestic economic challenges exist.

Both responsibilities must be managed.

Instead of concentrating so heavily on whether the Prime Minister appeared irritated during a press conference, perhaps our media organisations could devote more attention to the substance of government policies, the Opposition's alternatives and the evidence behind competing economic arguments.

Australians deserve journalism that informs rather than simply reinforces political divisions.

The Albanese Government should be judged on its decisions, policies and results. The Opposition should be judged on its alternative policies and its capacity to hold the Government accountable. And News Corp should be judged on the quality, accuracy, fairness and consistency of its journalism.

A free press is one of the foundations of democracy, but freedom of the press does not mean freedom from scrutiny.

The National Herald firmly believes that the Prime Minister deserves to be questioned, challenged and held accountable. But the office of Prime Minister also deserves a basic level of respect, regardless of the political party occupying it.

That respect should not be conditional on whether a media organisation agrees with the Government's politics.

News Corp has enormous influence over Australia's political conversation. With that influence comes responsibility. Its journalists and commentators should be prepared to examine their own reporting with the same enthusiasm they apply to examining politicians.

We do not expect News Corp to support the Albanese Government. We do not expect it to agree with Labor's policies. We do, however, expect journalism to be fair, consistent and professional.

There is a difference between holding a government to account and treating it as a political enemy.

And when a media organisation repeatedly appears to cross that line, Australians are entitled to ask whether it is informing the public or simply campaigning against a government it does not support.

The National Herald will continue to question governments of every political persuasion. We will also continue to question media organisations when their coverage deserves examination.

Because democracy requires more than politicians being held accountable. It requires those who report on them to be accountable as well.

A free press is essential. A fair press is just as important.

Its time there was a Royal Commission into NewsCorp and its links to the The Liberal Party - oh and by the way its time NewsCorp started paying tax.

11/11/2026

HEGSETH DEFENDS IRAN WAR AS IMPEACHMENT BID RAISES QUESTIONS ABOUT PRESIDENTIAL POWER

US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth has defended his conduct of the Iran war and other military operations, dismissing a Republican congressman’s attempt to impeach him as political sabotage.

At his first Pentagon press conference in six months on Tuesday, Hegseth attacked Kentucky Republican Thomas Massie, who introduced eight articles of impeachment alleging serious constitutional and legal violations.

Hegseth described the resolution as a political stunt driven by personal resentment. He maintained that the military operations under scrutiny were lawful, ordered by President Donald Trump and properly reported to Congress.

However, presidential authorisation does not automatically establish legality. The US Constitution gives Congress significant powers over war, while military personnel and civilian officials remain subject to domestic and international law.

WHAT HEGSETH IS ACCUSED OF

Massie’s allegations include conducting the Iran war without congressional authorisation, disregarding congressional restrictions and continuing hostilities beyond statutory time limits.

The resolution also raises concerns about civilian casualties, including the bombing of a girls’ school in Iran, and lethal US strikes against suspected drug-trafficking vessels in the Caribbean and eastern Pacific. Further allegations concern military operations in Yemen and Venezuela and action taken against Democratic Senator Mark Kelly.

These are allegations advanced in an impeachment resolution, not established findings of unlawful conduct. Massie argues that the central question is whether Congress retains its constitutional authority over decisions to wage war.

Hegseth rejects the accusations and says he would authorise the operations again.

JOURNALISTS WARNED BEFORE PRESS CONFERENCE

The press conference itself attracted controversy before Hegseth began speaking. According to The Washington Post, a Pentagon security official warned journalists they could be physically removed if they failed to maintain professional conduct. Reporters sought clarification about whether shouting questions could lead to removal but received no clear answer.

Hegseth subsequently took only a handful of questions, predominantly from conservative outlets. Journalists from several established news organisations were not called upon. No reporters were physically removed.

The incident follows longstanding disputes over Pentagon restrictions on press access and journalists’ ability to question military officials independently.

HOUSE BLOCKS IMMEDIATE IMPEACHMENT VOTE

The Republican-controlled House subsequently voted 211–204 to refer Massie’s impeachment resolution to the Judiciary Committee, preventing an immediate vote on whether to impeach Hegseth. The Pentagon welcomed the result as a victory.

Massie, who lost his Republican primary to a Trump-backed challenger, had argued that the allegations warranted congressional action regardless of party affiliation. Trump strongly defended Hegseth, publicly praising his press conference and attacking Massie.

Even if the House eventually votes to impeach Hegseth, removal would require a two-thirds majority in the Senate. The dispute raises a question extending beyond Hegseth’s political future: whether a president’s direction is sufficient justification for military actions challenged under the Constitution and laws governing armed conflict.

Congressional oversight is one of the mechanisms intended to test that question, not an automatic act of disloyalty to the military.

— The National Herald

Address

Albury, NSW

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Labor True Believers, Political Analysis and Satire posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Nearby government services